How ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity decide which practice to recommend
No AI company publishes exactly how its assistant chooses which practice to name. What is documented is the input: assistants that search the web draw on pages their crawlers can reach and on search indexes, and Google says its AI features are rooted in its core ranking systems and can draw on Business Profiles. The reasonable bet is to be easy to find, easy to verify and consistent everywhere.
What happens when a patient asks
Picture a hypothetical patient who types: "Who is a good dermatologist near me for eczema that takes Blue Cross?" Broadly, an assistant can answer in two ways.
It can answer from what its model learned in training, which may be months or years old and is not tied to any specific source. Or it can search the web first and build its answer from what it finds, usually showing links to those sources. For a question about local doctors, current hours and insurance, the search route is the useful one, and the major assistants document crawlers built for it.
Google describes one more step for AI Overviews and AI Mode: they may use a technique it calls query fan out, issuing multiple related searches across subtopics and data sources before writing the answer. So the patient's one question may become several searches: dermatologists nearby, eczema treatment, which practices accept that insurance, and what reviews say.
What the companies document
These facts come from the companies' own pages:
- Google: its generative AI features are rooted in its core Search ranking and quality systems. A page must be indexed and eligible to show a snippet to appear as a supporting link. Google Business Profiles can help businesses be visible in AI responses. Google has also said Gemini can be grounded in content from the Google Search index.
- OpenAI: OAI-SearchBot is used to surface websites in ChatGPT's search features, and sites that opt out of it are not shown in ChatGPT search answers. GPTBot is a separate crawler for training.
- Perplexity: PerplexityBot is designed to surface and link websites in Perplexity's search results and is not used to collect training data for foundation models.
- Anthropic: Claude-SearchBot crawls to improve search results for Claude users, and blocking it may reduce a site's visibility in those results.
None of these pages explains how one practice is chosen over another.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
What is reasonable to infer
From what is documented, a few inferences are sensible, though none is proven.
- An assistant cannot cite what it cannot reach. If your pages block the search crawlers or hide content behind scripts, you are at a disadvantage.
- Specific beats general. If the patient asks about eczema and insurance, a page that says you treat eczema and lists that insurer gives a searching system something to match. A services list does not.
- Agreement across sources builds confidence. When your site, your Google Business Profile and directory listings agree, every source supports the same answer. When they conflict, the assistant has to pick one, and may pick wrong.
- Reputation travels. Reviews and independent mentions are part of how Google measures local prominence, and assistants that search the web will find them too. Our guide on how AI uses reviews looks at this in detail.
Treat these as working assumptions you can test, not rules.
What nobody outside the companies knows
Be skeptical of anyone who claims certainty on these points:
- How much each assistant weighs your website against directories, reviews or maps data
- Whether review counts, star ratings or review text matter, and how much
- How personalization, location, past conversations or account settings change the answer
- Why the same question gives different practices on different days
The last point is easy to see for yourself. Ask the same question twice and you may get different names. That variability is why a single test tells you little, and why our guide on checking what AI says about your practice recommends repeating a fixed set of questions over time.
Why a specific page beats a general one
Patients ask assistants long, specific questions, often with a condition, a location and a constraint such as insurance, age or availability. The more of that question your site answers in plain words, the more material any system has to work with.
Compare two hypothetical pediatric practices. One has a homepage that says "comprehensive care for children". The other has pages that say, in plain sentences, that it sees newborns through age 18, offers same day sick visits, has a lactation consultant on staff, accepts specific plans and has evening hours on Tuesdays. Asked for a pediatrician with evening hours who helps with breastfeeding, a searching assistant has far more to go on with the second.
This is the case for one page per service, condition and procedure and for stating facts in full sentences.
What to do this month
- Check your robots.txt and hosting security settings to confirm OAI-SearchBot, PerplexityBot and Claude-SearchBot are not blocked.
- Update your Google Business Profile: categories, hours, services, photos and booking link, all matching your website.
- Make sure your site states, in text, the conditions you treat, the ages you see, the insurance you accept and your hours.
- Compare your listings on the major directories with your site and fix any that disagree. See your practice as an entity.
- Ask the major assistants your patients' questions, record the answers, and repeat monthly.
None of this depends on knowing an assistant's internal formula. It makes your practice easier to find and to describe correctly under any formula.
Checklist
- Search crawlers for ChatGPT, Perplexity and Claude can reach your site
- Your key pages are indexed in Google and show a normal snippet
- Your Google Business Profile is complete and current
- Conditions treated, ages seen, insurance and hours are stated in text on your site
- Directory listings match your website and Business Profile
- You run the same set of patient questions through the major assistants each month
Frequently asked
Does ChatGPT use Google to find practices?
OpenAI documents its own search crawler, OAI-SearchBot, for ChatGPT's search features, and does not describe its full list of search sources on that page. Do not assume that ranking well in Google guarantees an appearance in ChatGPT, or the reverse. Check each assistant directly.
Do AI assistants favor big health systems over independent practices?
There is no public evidence either way about a deliberate preference. Large systems often have more pages, more reviews and more mentions, which could make them easier to find. An independent practice can close that gap with specific pages and consistent listings.
Can I ask an AI company to recommend my practice?
None of the documentation we reviewed offers a way to request inclusion or better placement in answers. What you control is whether their search crawlers can reach your site and what your site and profiles say.
Why does the assistant recommend a practice that closed?
It may be relying on old training data or outdated listings. If your own practice information is wrong, fix it at the source the assistant cites, usually your website, Business Profile or a directory, then check again after a few weeks.
Sources
- AI features and your website, Google Search Central
- Optimizing your website for generative AI features on Google Search, Google Search Central
- Google's common crawlers, Google Search Central
- Overview of OpenAI crawlers, OpenAI
- Perplexity crawlers, Perplexity
- Does Anthropic crawl data from the web, and how can site owners block the crawler?, Anthropic
- Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.