Common mistakes medical practice websites make
Most practice websites lose patients for ordinary reasons: booking is hard to find, basic facts are out of date, the site is slow on a phone, and nobody is watching the forms. Each mistake in this series is common, easy to check and fixable without a full redesign.
Why these mistakes matter more than design
When a practice website underperforms, the instinct is to redesign it. New colors, new photos, a new agency. But the patients you are losing rarely leave because the site looks dated. They leave because they could not find the phone number on their phone, the hours were wrong, the booking button was nowhere to be seen, or the form they filled in on Sunday was never answered.
These are not design problems. They are small, specific failures in the path from "I need a doctor" to "I have an appointment". Each one is cheap to fix, and together they often matter more than anything a redesign would change.
How to use this series
Each guide covers one mistake: what it looks like, how to check your own site in a few minutes, and what to do about it. Check them on your phone, because most patients will see your site on one.
You do not need to fix everything at once. Work through them in order of how close each one sits to the booking:
- Booking, phone and hours, because they decide whether a ready patient can reach you
- Speed and mobile layout, because a slow page loses people before they read anything
- Trust signals such as real photos, provider bios and reviews
- The technical foundations: redirects, accessibility, tracking and ownership
One fix a week adds up quickly.
Start with these four
If you only have an hour, check these first. They sit closest to the moment a patient decides to book.
- No online booking, or booking buried three clicks deep
- A phone number missing from the header, or not tappable on a phone
- Hours, address and accepted insurance out of date
- A slow mobile site and huge uncompressed images
Then work down the full list below. If you would rather see where your site stands right away, the free audit checks your speed, structured data, indexing, reviews and whether AI assistants recommend you.
Every guide in this series
- 1No online booking, or booking buried three clicks deep
If a patient cannot see how to book within a few seconds of landing on your site, many will leave and book with the next practice in the results. Put a clear booking button on every page, let new patients book without calling, and keep the path from button to confirmed time short.
- 2Phone number missing from the header, or not tappable on a phone
Put your main scheduling number in the header of every page, as real text inside a tap to call link, so a patient on a phone can call you with one tap. A number hidden in the footer, baked into an image or missing the link makes a ready patient copy it by hand, and many will not bother.
- 3Hours, address and accepted insurance out of date
Wrong hours, an old suite number or a stale insurance list sends patients to a locked door or a surprise bill, and it teaches them not to trust anything else on your site. Give one person ownership of these facts, keep one source of truth, and check every place they appear on a fixed schedule.
- 4Stock photos instead of your real providers and office
Patients choosing a practice want to see the people they will meet and the place they will walk into, and generic stock images of models in white coats tell them nothing. Replace the photos that carry the most weight first: provider headshots, the entrance, the waiting room and an exam room, taken in good light at your own office.
- 5Provider bios with no credentials, specialties or photo
A provider bio is often the page that decides the booking, because patients choose a person. Every bio needs a real photo, full credentials and board certification, the conditions and procedures that provider focuses on, where and when they see patients, and a button to book with them.
- 6One page for every service instead of a page per service and condition
A single Services page that lists everything you treat gives Google and AI assistants nothing specific to match a patient's search, and gives the patient no evidence that you handle their problem. Give each major service and condition its own page that answers the questions patients ask before they book.
- 7A slow mobile site and huge uncompressed images
Most practice websites are slow on phones for a few fixable reasons: oversized photos, too many third party scripts and underpowered hosting. Test your key pages on mobile with PageSpeed Insights, fix the images first, and aim to pass Google's Core Web Vitals thresholds for real visitors.
- 8Contact forms that land in an inbox nobody checks
A contact form is a promise that someone will answer. When submissions go to an old address, a spam folder or a former employee's inbox, patients who reached out are lost without anyone noticing. Test every form this week, route submissions to a monitored shared inbox or your practice software, and publish a response time you can keep.
- 9A redesign that wiped out your Google rankings (no redirects)
When a redesign changes page addresses without permanent redirects, patients and Google hit dead pages and the rankings those pages earned fade away. If it already happened, rebuild the list of old URLs, send each one to its closest new page with a permanent redirect, and fix your internal links. The sooner you act, the more you are likely to recover.
- 10Pop ups that cover the page on mobile
A pop up that fills a phone screen stands between a patient and the phone number or booking button they came for, and Google warns that intrusive dialogs can lead to poor search performance. Replace full screen pop ups with small banners or messages inside the page, and keep only the notices you truly need.
- 11Not accessible to patients with disabilities (and the ADA lawsuit risk)
Your website is one of the main ways patients with disabilities reach your practice, and the Department of Justice says the ADA applies to the websites of businesses open to the public, including medical offices. The ADA does not set one technical standard for private practices, but WCAG is the yardstick most people use, so fix the common barriers first and keep testing.
- 12Tracking pixels on pages where patients enter health information
If an advertising or analytics tag sits on your booking pages, forms, symptom tools or patient portal login, it can send what patients type or select to that company, and HHS treats that as a disclosure of protected health information. A 2024 court ruling struck down part of HHS's guidance, but not the part about pages where patients enter health information or log in.
- 13Name, address and phone that differ from your Google Business Profile
When your website, Google Business Profile and directory listings show different names, suite numbers or phone numbers, patients call the wrong line or drive to the wrong door, and search engines have to guess which version is true. Choose one exact version of your name, address and phone, use it everywhere, and clean up the old listings that still carry the past.
- 14Medical jargon instead of the words patients search
Patients search in their own words, such as "pain on the bottom of my heel" rather than "plantar fasciitis", so pages written only in clinical terms miss them and confuse the ones who do arrive. Lead with the patient's words, then introduce the medical term, and keep sentences short and plain.
- 15No clear path for new patients
New patients arrive with questions existing patients never ask: are you taking new patients, do you accept my insurance, do I need a referral, and what happens at the first visit. If your site makes them hunt for those answers, many give up. Build one clear New Patients page and link to it from the header of every page.
- 16A footer that still says 2019
An old copyright year will not hurt your copyright or break your site, but patients read it as a sign nobody is minding the website, and it usually sits next to bigger problems: stale contact details, dead links and an outdated privacy notice. Fix the year in a minute, then use the footer as a monthly checkpoint for everything else that goes stale.
- 17Your agency owns your domain, not you
If your marketing agency registered your practice's domain in its own name or account, it controls your web address, your email and years of search history, and leaving can mean starting over. Check who the registrant is today, and move the domain into an account your practice owns while the relationship is still friendly.
- 18Patient portal login nobody can find
Existing patients come to your website to log in, pay a bill or message their care team, and when the portal link is buried they call the front desk instead. Put a clearly labeled patient portal link in the header of every page, keep it separate from new patient booking, and make sure it opens your practice's login.
- 19Duplicate pages across multiple locations
Location pages that are copies of each other with only the town name swapped give Google little reason to show more than one of them, and pages built for towns where you have no office can look like the doorway pages Google's spam policies describe. Give each real location a page with facts only that office has: its address, hours, providers, services, parking and directions.
- 20No way to reach you after hours
Patients look you up in the evening and on weekends, and a site that only says "call during business hours" sends them to urgent care, the emergency room or another practice. Tell after hours visitors exactly what to do: book or request a visit online, reach the on call clinician for urgent problems, and call 911 for emergencies.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Frequently asked
What is the most common mistake on medical practice websites?
Making it hard to book. Booking buttons hidden on a contact page, request forms that promise a callback, and phone numbers that are not tappable on mobile all send ready patients to the next practice in the results.
Do I need a new website to fix these?
Usually not. Most of these mistakes can be fixed on your current site in an afternoon each. A redesign makes sense when the platform itself is the problem, for example when it is too slow or you cannot edit your own pages.
How do I check my own website for these mistakes?
Open it on your phone and try to book as a new patient, then call the number from the header, then compare the hours and address with your Google Business Profile. Each guide in this series includes a quick check you can do yourself.