Patient reviews and credibility
Reviews are often what decides between two practices a patient has never visited. Earning them steadily, answering them without disclosing patient information, and following Google's and the FTC's rules matter far more than chasing a perfect rating.
Why reviews carry extra weight in medicine
A patient choosing a doctor cannot judge clinical skill in advance. So they judge what they can: what other patients say about the wait, the front desk, how well the doctor listened and explained, and whether the bill matched what they were told. Reviews are the closest thing they have to a recommendation from someone who has been there.
Reviews also shape who gets found, not only who gets picked. Google says the number of reviews and positive ratings can help a business's local ranking. Google Maps now uses Gemini to summarize what reviews say about a place, so the themes patients repeat can become the one line a searcher reads about you. AI assistants that search the web can pick up review sites and directory profiles as well.
Three rules that keep you out of trouble
Most review problems in medical practices come from breaking one of three rules.
- Never disclose patient information in a reply. HHS has settled with practices that revealed patient details while answering online reviews, including a New Jersey psychiatric practice that paid $30,000 after its responses to negative online reviews disclosed patients' protected health information.
- Ask every patient, not only the happy ones. Google's policy prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews, and the FTC advises businesses not to ask only customers they expect to be pleased. Tools that screen patients first and send only satisfied ones to Google are doing exactly that.
- No fake, bought or insider reviews. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews, in effect since October 2024, lets the agency seek civil penalties for fake reviews, for incentives tied to a positive rating and for undisclosed reviews by managers and staff.
This page and the guides below are general information, not legal advice. Check your own policies with your compliance officer or a health care attorney.
Start here
If you only read four guides in this hub, read these.
- Why reviews decide which doctor a patient picks explains what patients actually read, and a 15 minute way to read your own reviews as a stranger would.
- How to ask for reviews without breaking HIPAA covers a neutral request, vendors and what not to say.
- Responding to negative reviews without confirming someone is a patient gives the one test every reply must pass, with templates.
- Review gating: why it breaks Google's rules shows how to check whether your review software is doing it.
Then work through the rest of the hub, from how many reviews you need to how AI assistants use them.
Every guide in this series
- 1Why reviews decide which doctor a patient picks
Most patients cannot judge a doctor's clinical skill before a visit, so they judge what they can: what other patients say about waits, staff, communication and results. Reviews also feed Google's local ranking and the summaries AI tools give, so they shape who gets found as well as who gets picked.
- 2How many reviews you need, and how recent they should be
There is no universal number. You need enough reviews to look established next to the practices you compete with for your main searches, and enough recent ones that a patient sees current experiences. Benchmark the top map results for your specialty and town, then set a monthly pace you can keep.
- 3How to ask for reviews without breaking HIPAA
You can ask patients for reviews. The HIPAA risk is in the details: what the request reveals about the visit, which vendor handles patient contact data, and what you say if the patient replies. Send a plain, neutral request to every patient, through a vendor under a business associate agreement, and never offer anything in return.
- 4Responding to negative reviews without confirming someone is a patient
Reply to negative reviews in a way that would read the same whether or not the reviewer was ever your patient: no names, no visit details, no confirmation of care. Acknowledge the concern in general terms, state your standards, and invite the person to contact the office privately. Practices have paid HHS settlements for doing otherwise.
- 5Google versus Healthgrades versus Zocdoc versus Yelp
For most practices, Google reviews matter most, because they appear on the map and in search where patients choose. Healthgrades matters when it ranks for your doctors' names, Zocdoc reviews come mainly from patients who book through Zocdoc, and Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all. Each has its own rules, so treat them differently.
- 6Review gating: why it breaks Google's rules
Review gating means screening patients first and sending only the happy ones to Google. Google's policy forbids selectively soliciting positive reviews, the FTC warns against asking only customers you expect to be pleased, and some review tools include this kind of screening as a feature. Send the same review request to every patient instead.
- 7Fake reviews and the FTC rule
Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials has let the agency seek civil penalties for fake reviews, incentives tied to a positive rating, undisclosed reviews by managers and staff, and threats used to remove negative reviews. Your practice is also responsible for what marketing vendors do on its behalf.
- 8Showing reviews on your website the right way
Showing reviews on your site can reassure patients at the moment they decide, but it does not earn star ratings in Google for your own practice, and how you choose and label them matters. Link to your public profiles, feature reviews that represent the whole picture, and get written permission before you publish a patient's words as a testimonial.
- 9Credibility beyond stars: board certification, affiliations, awards
Star ratings tell patients how a visit felt. Credentials tell them whether a doctor is qualified for their problem. Show board certification with the exact certifying board, training, hospital affiliations and the conditions each provider treats, make every claim verifiable, and be wary of awards that are paid for.
- 10How AI assistants use reviews when recommending a practice
AI assistants do not just count stars. Google says Maps uses Gemini to summarize what people like about a place from its reviews, and assistants that search the web can draw on the review sites and profiles they find. The themes patients repeat, such as long waits or a doctor who explains things well, can become the one line an assistant says about you.
- 11Review velocity: why steady beats a burst
A steady flow of reviews tied to real visits keeps your profile current for patients and looks like what it is: an honest record. A sudden burst from a one day campaign or a staff contest can look like manipulation to Google, whose policy names unusual volumes or patterns of reviews as a sign of rating manipulation.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Frequently asked
What is the most important thing a practice can do about reviews?
Ask every patient, the same way, after every visit, through a simple link. A steady flow of genuine reviews keeps your profile current, dilutes the occasional bad one and follows the platforms' rules. Everything else, from replies to website display, builds on that.
Are we allowed to reply to reviews at all under HIPAA?
Yes, as long as the reply discloses nothing about the person or their care, including the fact that they were your patient. A short, general reply that invites the reviewer to contact the office privately is safe and shows prospective patients that you listen.
Which review site matters most for a medical practice?
For most practices, Google, because its reviews appear on the map and in search where patients choose. After that, focus on whichever sites show up on the first screen when someone searches your practice or your doctors by name, which varies by market and specialty.
Sources
- HHS Office for Civil Rights Reaches Agreement with Health Care Provider in New Jersey That Disclosed Patient Information in Response to Negative Online Reviews, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user generated content policy, Google Maps Help
- Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers, Federal Trade Commission
- The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers, Federal Trade Commission
- Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
- Google Maps updates: Gemini arrives, Immersive View expands and more, Google