How to ask for reviews without breaking HIPAA
You can ask patients for reviews. The HIPAA risk is in the details: what the request reveals about the visit, which vendor handles patient contact data, and what you say if the patient replies. Send a plain, neutral request to every patient, through a vendor under a business associate agreement, and never offer anything in return.
Asking is allowed, so here is what the rules actually cover
Google explicitly allows businesses to ask customers for reviews of genuine experiences, and even provides a review link and QR code for the purpose. What it prohibits is offering incentives, discouraging negative reviews, selectively asking for positive ones, and pressuring people. The FTC's guidance for marketers says the same about selective asking: do not ask for reviews only from customers you think will leave positive ones.
HIPAA does not ban review requests. It governs protected health information, which HHS describes as individually identifiable information relating to a person's health, the care provided to them or payment for that care. The fact that a named person had a particular procedure at your practice is exactly that kind of information. So the HIPAA question is not whether you ask. It is what your request reveals, to whom, and who handles the data along the way.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Review your setup with your compliance officer or a health care attorney.
Keep the request itself neutral
A review request should reveal nothing about the visit beyond what the patient already knows. Anyone who sees the patient's phone screen, email preview or mailbox should learn nothing about their health.
A safe template looks like this:
"Thank you for choosing [Practice name]. If you would like to share your experience, you can leave a review here: [link]. Your feedback helps other patients find care."
Things to leave out:
- The procedure, test or condition, such as "your colonoscopy" or "your fertility consult"
- The provider's subspecialty when it would reveal the reason for the visit
- Any suggestion of a rating or of what to write
Take extra care when your practice name itself is sensitive, such as an addiction treatment, HIV or behavioral health practice. Use the channel the patient chose for communications, and consider whether a request is appropriate at all for visits where discretion matters most.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
The vendor question: who touches patient data
If you use software that sends review requests automatically after each visit, it pulls names, phone numbers, email addresses, visit dates and often the provider from your EHR or practice management system. That is protected health information.
HHS explains that a business associate is a person or organization that creates, receives, maintains or transmits protected health information on behalf of a covered entity, and that a covered entity may share that information with a business associate only with satisfactory written assurances, usually a business associate agreement.
Before you connect any review tool, ask the vendor:
- Will you sign a business associate agreement?
- Exactly which fields do you pull from our system, and can we limit them?
- What appears in the messages you send, and can we control the wording?
- Where is the data stored, who can see it and how long do you keep it?
- Does your default setup screen patients by satisfaction before showing the review link?
A vendor that will not sign a business associate agreement should not receive patient data.
Ask everyone, the same way, with nothing attached
Google's policy is specific about what merchants may not do when soliciting reviews. It prohibits:
- Offering incentives such as payment, discounts or free services in exchange for any review
- Discouraging or prohibiting negative reviews, or selectively soliciting positive ones
- Requiring or pressuring customers to leave reviews while they are on the premises
- Asking staff to collect a set number of reviews, or asking for reviews with specific content, including content that names a staff member
The FTC's rule on consumer reviews separately bans incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment. Yelp goes further than either and asks businesses not to request reviews at all.
In practice: send the same request after every visit, to every patient, with no gift, raffle or discount attached. If you exclude anyone, base the exclusion on privacy or clinical reasons that are written down and applied consistently, never on whether you expect a good review. The guide on review gating explains why screening by satisfaction crosses the line.
In the office: a QR code yes, a tablet at checkout no
Google suggests displaying your review QR code in your place of business, and printing your review link on receipts and in thank you emails. Its policy also says merchants should not require or pressure customers to leave reviews while on the premises.
Those two fit together. A small sign at checkout with a QR code, or a card handed out with the visit summary, invites a review the patient can write later, at home, in their own words. A staff member handing a patient a tablet and waiting while they type is pressure.
The same applies to providers. Mentioning at the end of a visit that feedback is welcome is fine. Asking a patient to post a five star review before they leave is not.
When a patient replies to your request
Some patients answer the review request directly, by text or email, with a complaint or with details about their care. Treat that reply as a patient communication, not as review content.
- Route it to a manager or the right clinical team member the same day
- Respond through a secure channel, not in a public reply
- Do not quote it, post it or paraphrase it anywhere public
- If they then post a public review, reply to that in general terms only
The public reply is where most HIPAA trouble with reviews actually happens. Before you answer any review, read responding to negative reviews without confirming someone is a patient.
Checklist
- Use one neutral template that names no procedure, test or condition
- Get a signed business associate agreement from your review vendor
- Limit the data fields the vendor pulls to what it needs
- Send the same request after every visit, to every patient
- Offer no gifts, discounts or raffles for reviews
- Turn off any satisfaction screening before the review link
- Display a QR code, but never hand patients a device to review on
- Route replies to review requests to a manager the same day
Frequently asked
Can we text patients a link to review us?
Yes, if the patient has agreed to receive texts from you and the message reveals nothing about their visit. Keep it short and neutral, send it through a vendor under a business associate agreement, and honor any request to stop.
Can the doctor ask for a review in the exam room?
A light mention that feedback is welcome, with a card or QR code to use later, is reasonable. Asking the patient to post right then, or to give a particular rating, is the kind of pressure Google's policy prohibits on the premises.
Do we need patient authorization to send review requests?
That depends on how your practice handles patient communications and what the request contains, so ask your compliance officer. What you control directly is that the request reveals nothing about the visit and that any vendor handling the data is under a business associate agreement.
Should we ask for Yelp reviews too?
No. Yelp asks businesses not to solicit reviews at all, and says its software tries to identify reviews that appear to have been requested and not recommend them. Focus your requests on Google and on any healthcare platform whose rules allow asking.
Can we offer a small thank you gift after a review?
Not for a Google review. Google prohibits incentives of any kind in exchange for reviews, and the FTC's rule bans incentives tied to positive sentiment. Thank patients for their feedback in words, and keep gifts out of it.
Sources
- Tips to get more reviews, Google Business Profile Help
- Create a Google link or QR code to request reviews, Google Business Profile Help
- Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user generated content policy, Google Maps Help
- Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers, Federal Trade Commission
- Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials, Federal Trade Commission
- Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Business Associates, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Don't Ask for Reviews, Yelp Support Center
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.