Google versus Healthgrades versus Zocdoc versus Yelp

Updated November 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Short answer

For most practices, Google reviews matter most, because they appear on the map and in search where patients choose. Healthgrades matters when it ranks for your doctors' names, Zocdoc reviews come mainly from patients who book through Zocdoc, and Yelp asks businesses not to request reviews at all. Each has its own rules, so treat them differently.

Start with where patients actually see you

Before deciding which platform deserves effort, find out which ones your patients encounter. On a phone, search your practice name, each provider's name, and your specialty plus town. For each search, note which review sites appear on the first screen and what rating each shows.

Google's own reviews usually sit at the top of those screens, because they appear inside the map results and in the profile that shows for your name. Directory sites tend to appear for individual doctors' names. How visible Yelp is varies by market.

The sites that appear for your names are the ones to claim, correct and monitor. The site where you can legitimately ask every patient for a review, and where most patients will see it, is the one to build. For most practices that is Google.

Google

Who can review: anyone signed into a Google account. Google notes that customers can create an account with a non Gmail address.

Can you ask? Yes. Google offers a review link and QR code and encourages businesses to remind customers to leave reviews. Its policy prohibits incentives, discouraging negative reviews, selectively soliciting positive ones, pressuring customers on the premises and conflict of interest reviews such as those from employees.

Can you reply? Yes, once your profile is verified. Replies are public and reviewed against Google's policies.

Why it matters: Google says reviews are part of prominence, one of the main factors in local results, and your rating and count appear next to your name on the map. Google also says your score is the average of all ratings published on Google, and that your profile may show reviews from other sites, which you cannot choose.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

Healthgrades

Who can review: patients, who can choose to include their name, city and state or remain anonymous, according to Healthgrades' own description of its reviews.

Integrity rules: Healthgrades says reviews must follow its community guidelines, that live reviews can be flagged for additional review, that doctors cannot pay for good reviews or to remove negative ones, and that fraudulent reviews are removed.

Your profile: Healthgrades invites doctors to claim their free profile. Profiles often exist whether or not you have claimed them, so check yours for the right address, phone, insurance and specialties.

Why it matters: Healthgrades profiles often show up when patients search a doctor by name, and your own name search will tell you whether that is true in your market. Claim each provider's profile, correct the details and reply to reviews with the same privacy care you use everywhere else.

Zocdoc

Who can review: Zocdoc says its own patient reviews come only from patients who booked through Zocdoc and attended the appointment, submitted through a logged in account or a visit specific link. It also displays clearly labeled partner reviews collected by third party survey providers, and in some cases supplemental reviews shared by the practice from existing patients.

Can you ask? Zocdoc asks patients for feedback after every Zocdoc appointment. Its patient pages say patients can leave a review up to 120 days after the appointment.

Moderation: Zocdoc says it publishes positive and negative reviews, moderates every review against its guidelines, and prohibits providers from unduly influencing reviews or taking action against patients who leave negative ones.

Why it matters: if you list on Zocdoc, its reviews drive bookings inside that marketplace. If you do not, they do not apply to you. For the wider tradeoff, see Healthgrades, Zocdoc and marketplaces: rent or own?.

Yelp

Who can review: anyone with a Yelp account. Yelp's content guidelines say people should not review their own business, their employer or their competitors.

Can you ask? No. Yelp tells businesses not to ask anyone for reviews, including customers, mailing lists, friends and family, and not to ask for reviews after collecting feedback through surveys or forms. It says staff should never compete to collect reviews.

What happens if you ask: Yelp says its recommendation software tries to identify reviews that appear to have been requested and not recommend them, so asking can work against you. It also runs a Consumer Alerts program that can place a notice on a business page when it learns of incentivized reviews.

Why it matters: in some cities and specialties, Yelp ranks for practice names. Claim your page, keep its details accurate, reply professionally, and leave the reviews to arrive on their own.

Where to put your effort

A practical order for most practices:

  1. Google, for every location and every provider with their own profile. This is where you ask every patient, every time.
  2. The directories that rank for your names, often Healthgrades and sometimes others. Claim, correct and monitor them.
  3. Zocdoc, only if you use it for booking. Its reviews follow the bookings.
  4. Yelp, claimed and accurate, but never solicited.

Send each patient one review link, not a menu of five sites. A single clear request gets more responses, and it keeps you inside each platform's rules. Wherever you reply, the HIPAA rules are the same: say nothing that confirms the reviewer was a patient or reveals anything about their care. The guide on responding to negative reviews has safe wording.

Platform policies change, so check each site's current rules before you change your process. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Checklist

  • Search your practice and provider names and list the review sites on the first screen
  • Claim and verify every Google profile for your locations and providers
  • Claim each provider's Healthgrades profile and correct the details
  • Send patients a single review link, usually to Google
  • Never solicit Yelp reviews, but keep your Yelp page accurate
  • Reply on every platform using the same privacy safe templates
  • Recheck the platforms' rules once a year

Frequently asked

Should we send patients a page with links to every review site?

Usually not. One clear link gets more responses than a list of choices, and some platforms, such as Yelp, ask businesses not to solicit at all. Point most requests to Google, where most patients will see the review.

Do Healthgrades reviews show up on our Google profile?

They can. Google says Business Profiles may show reviews from other sites, that you cannot choose which sites appear, and that problems with those reviews must be raised with the original site. The Google rating itself is the average of reviews published on Google.

Are Zocdoc reviews more trustworthy than others?

Zocdoc's own patient reviews are tied to appointments booked through its platform, which limits who can post them. That makes them useful for patients booking on Zocdoc. They do not replace Google reviews, which reach patients who never visit Zocdoc.

Does Yelp matter for medical practices?

It depends on your market. In some cities Yelp pages rank well for practice names, and in others they rarely appear. Check your own name searches. If Yelp shows up, claim and maintain the page, but do not ask patients to review you there.

Sources

  1. Tips to get more reviews, Google Business Profile Help
  2. Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user generated content policy, Google Maps Help
  3. Manage customer reviews, Google Business Profile Help
  4. Understand review scores for local places and businesses, Google Business Profile Help
  5. About third-party reviews, Google Business Profile Help
  6. Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
  7. Patient Reviews, Healthgrades
  8. How to Stay HIPAA-Compliant When Responding to Patient Reviews, Healthgrades
  9. Verified Reviews, Zocdoc
  10. Verified Reviews on Zocdoc: How We Ensure Real Patient Feedback, Zocdoc
  11. Don't Ask for Reviews, Yelp Support Center
  12. Content Guidelines, Yelp
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.