Healthgrades, Zocdoc and marketplaces: rent or own your patient flow?
Claim and correct your free marketplace profiles no matter what, because patients and AI assistants read them whether you do or not. Paying a marketplace for bookings is renting patient flow: it can fill open slots quickly, but you pay for every new patient it sends, so compare the fee with what a new patient is worth to you and keep building the website and Google profile you own.
Rent or own: the core tradeoff
Doctor marketplaces sit between patients and practices. A patient searches by specialty, insurance and availability, sees a list of doctors, and books. The marketplace brings the audience, and you bring the open time.
That is renting. It works the day you switch it on, and it stops the day you stop paying. The patient's first relationship is often with the marketplace's app, and the next time they need care they may search there again and pick someone else.
Owning is your website, your Google Business Profile and your reviews. They take months to build, but they keep working without a per patient fee, and patients who find you there come to you directly.
Most practices end up with a mix. The useful question is not "marketplace or not" but "for which providers, which visit types and for how long".
Claim the free profiles either way
Your practice and your providers probably already have profiles on Healthgrades and similar directories, whether anyone at the practice created them or not. Healthgrades says it aggregates provider information from publicly available sources, and uses government and commercial data to decide which procedures and insurance options to display. That data can be incomplete or out of date.
These profiles matter beyond the patients who visit them. They can appear in Google results for your providers' names, and AI assistants may read them when describing you. A profile that lists an old address or the wrong insurance sends that error everywhere.
For each provider:
- Find the profile using the provider's NPI and claim it through the site's provider tools. Healthgrades offers a free claim and a Healthgrades Pro account for edits
- Correct the office addresses, phone, photo, insurance carriers, conditions and procedures
- Add a link to your website and your booking page
- Set a reminder to check twice a year, and whenever a provider joins, leaves or changes locations
Consistency across these profiles is part of how search engines and assistants recognize your practice, as explained in your practice as an entity.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
How paid marketplaces charge, and what to ask
Pricing models differ by marketplace and change over time, so get the current terms in writing. As one example, Zocdoc describes its standard marketplace as pay per booking: a one time fee when a new patient books through it, with no subscription fee, and controls to cap or pause marketplace spend. It also says its scheduling, intake and reminder tools are available for a practice's whole patient base at no charge.
Before you sign with any marketplace, ask:
- What exactly counts as a billable booking, and how is a new patient defined?
- Are you charged if the patient cancels, reschedules or does not show up, and how do you dispute a charge?
- Can you choose which providers, locations and visit types appear?
- Can you set a monthly cap or pause, and how quickly does it take effect?
- Does the booking write directly into your EHR schedule, or does staff re-enter it?
- Can you contact the patient directly for reminders and follow up, using your own systems?
- What is the minimum term, and what happens to your profile and reviews if you leave?
The answers to questions 1 and 2 decide your real cost per patient.
Run the numbers for your own practice
A booking fee only makes sense next to what that patient is worth to you. You need two numbers: the effective cost per new patient who actually arrives, and the value of a new patient for that visit type.
Here is an illustration using round, made up figures. Replace them with your own.
- Suppose the marketplace fee works out to $100 per new patient booking.
- Suppose you are charged for every booking and one in five of those patients never arrives. You pay for five bookings to see four patients, so your cost per arrived patient is $125.
- Suppose a new patient in this visit type brings $300 in collections over the first year, after your direct costs.
In this example the marketplace earns back its fee within the first year. Change any input, such as a lower value visit type or a high no show rate, and the answer can flip. Calculate it separately for each provider and visit type. The methods are in what a new patient is worth and patient acquisition cost by channel.
When a marketplace makes sense, and when it does not
A paid marketplace tends to make sense when:
- A new provider has an empty schedule and needs patients now, while your own channels catch up
- You are opening a new location with no reviews or rankings yet
- Patients in your specialty shop heavily by insurance and next available time
- You have specific visit types or times that go unfilled, such as early mornings
It tends not to make sense when:
- Your schedule is already booked out for weeks
- The visit types it fills are low value or poorly reimbursed
- Staff spend significant time re-entering bookings or chasing no shows from it
- It outranks your own website for your providers' names, and you are paying for patients who were already looking for you
That last point is worth checking. Search each provider's name. If a marketplace profile appears above your own provider page, strengthen that page and your Google Business Profile, as covered in protecting your name.
Keep your own front door open
Whatever you decide about paid listings, keep investing in the channels you own, so a marketplace is a choice, not a dependency.
- Offer online booking on your own website and Google Business Profile, so patients who find you directly do not have to go through a marketplace
- Ask every new patient, including marketplace patients, for a Google review after their visit
- Track marketplace patients as their own source, so you can compare their show rate, visit mix and retention with patients from other channels
- Review the marketplace each quarter against your capacity. When a provider's schedule fills, reduce or pause spend for that provider
The goal is to use marketplaces for what they do well, filling open time quickly, while your own website and profile gradually carry more of the load.
Checklist
- Every provider's Healthgrades profile claimed and corrected
- Marketplace profiles link to your website and booking page
- Billable booking and new patient definitions confirmed in writing
- Cost per arrived patient calculated for each provider and visit type
- Monthly cap set, with a plan to pause when schedules fill
- Marketplace patients tracked as their own source
Frequently asked
Is Zocdoc worth it for a medical practice?
It depends on your specialty, open capacity and the value of the visit types it fills. Calculate the cost per patient who actually arrives and compare it with what that patient is worth to you. It is often most useful for new providers and new locations.
Can I delete my Healthgrades profile?
Healthgrades describes options to add or remove a profile from its search results through its provider tools. For most practices, claiming and correcting the profile is the better choice, because it can appear near the top of the results for a provider's name.
Do marketplace patients stay with the practice?
Some do and some do not, and it varies by practice. Track it yourself: tag marketplace patients in your EHR and check after a year how many returned for a second visit, compared with patients from your own website and referrals.
Do marketplace reviews help my Google ranking?
Google says the number of reviews and positive ratings on your Business Profile can help your local ranking. Marketplace reviews mainly help patients on those sites and may be read by AI assistants. Ask for Google reviews from all new patients, including those who booked through a marketplace.
Sources
- Zocdoc provider ROI: understanding cost and value, Zocdoc
- Transparency and control for providers on Zocdoc, Zocdoc
- Healthgrades Help Center, Healthgrades
- Healthgrades self service for providers, Healthgrades
- How to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.