Responding to negative reviews without confirming someone is a patient
Reply to negative reviews in a way that would read the same whether or not the reviewer was ever your patient: no names, no visit details, no confirmation of care. Acknowledge the concern in general terms, state your standards, and invite the person to contact the office privately. Practices have paid HHS settlements for doing otherwise.
Why this is the review mistake that costs money
HHS's Office for Civil Rights has resolved several cases against practices that disclosed patient information while answering online reviews.
- Manasa Health Center, a New Jersey psychiatric practice, paid $30,000 in 2023. Its resolution agreement says it disclosed the protected health information of four patients in response to their negative reviews on Google.
- New Vision Dental in California paid $23,000 in 2022. The complaint alleged that replies on its Yelp page sometimes gave patients' full names where they had used only Yelp names, and included details about visits and insurance that the reviews had not mentioned.
- Elite Dental Associates in Dallas paid $10,000 in 2019 to settle social media disclosures of patients' information.
In the Manasa and New Vision corrective action plans, OCR required written policies, workforce training and breach notices to the affected patients, and New Vision had to remove the offending posts. A defensive reply written in a few minutes can turn into a formal corrective action plan.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Have your compliance officer or a health care attorney review your reply policy.
The test every reply must pass
Before posting, ask one question: would this reply be equally true if the reviewer had never been seen at this practice?
If yes, it is probably safe. If the reply only makes sense because you know who they are, it discloses something. Under HIPAA, information that identifies a person and relates to the care they received is protected, and confirming that someone was your patient reveals exactly that.
This holds even when the reviewer has told the world their own story. A patient can post their diagnosis, their surgeon's name and every detail of their visit. That does not give you permission to confirm it, correct it or add to it. HHS describes an authorization to disclose as a written document in specific terms, not a public post. Answer the concern, never the case. For the wider picture of what HIPAA covers online, see HIPAA on your website.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Reply templates for common complaints
Adapt these to your voice. Each works whether or not the reviewer is a patient.
Long wait: "We are sorry to hear about this experience. We work to keep wait times short and know how valuable your time is. Please call our office manager at the main number so we can learn more."
Billing: "Thank you for raising this. Billing questions deserve clear answers, and our billing team is glad to review any concern. Please contact the office directly so we can help."
Rude staff: "We expect every person who contacts our office to be treated with courtesy. We take this seriously and would welcome the chance to speak with you directly."
Unhappy with care or outcome: "We are sorry you are disappointed. Privacy rules prevent us from discussing any individual's care online, but we take concerns like this seriously. Please contact our practice manager so we can talk privately."
Possibly not a patient: "We take all feedback seriously. We would like to understand this concern, so please contact our office directly."
What never to say
Each of these feels like reasonable self defense, and each one discloses something.
- "We reviewed your chart" or "Our records show"
- "As we discussed at your appointment" or "when you were here on Tuesday"
- "You missed your last two appointments"
- "Your insurance did not cover" or anything about a balance
- "We are sorry your knee is still hurting" or any mention of a condition
- "Dr. [name] saw you for" or any detail of who provided care
- The reviewer's real name, if they posted under a nickname
- "We have no record of you", which confirms you checked
Google's general advice for business replies suggests addressing reviewers by name and acknowledging their specific feedback. That works for a restaurant. For a medical practice, keep replies general instead. Google also asks businesses never to share a reviewer's private information.
Taking it offline, and what the FTC rule adds
Inviting a reviewer to contact you privately is the right move, and the FTC's guidance on its consumer review rule says the rule does not prohibit contacting people who post negative reviews to resolve their concerns, or asking satisfied customers to update a review.
The same guidance draws lines you should not cross:
- Do not make false accusations about the reviewer that you know are false or make with reckless disregard for the truth
- Do not use threats or intimidation to get a review removed or changed
- Do not threaten legal action unless you have a legitimate basis
And do not offer anything in exchange for removing or changing a review. Google prohibits incentives for revising or removing negative reviews, and the FTC warns that paying to remove truthful negative reviews may violate the FTC Act.
When you do speak privately, it is a patient conversation. Use a secure channel and document it like any other complaint.
When to report a review instead of replying
Some reviews break the platform's rules, and reporting them is better than arguing. On Google, policy violations include fake engagement, content from someone with a conflict of interest such as a competitor or former employee, harassment and off topic content. Report those through your Business Profile. Google says review evaluation typically takes several days, and you can appeal once if a report is denied.
Google also says not to report a review just because you disagree with it. A patient's honest, negative opinion is not a policy violation.
If you see a sudden wave of one star reviews followed by a demand for money to remove them, Google treats that as an extortion scam. Do not pay or engage, collect the evidence and use Google's extortion report form. For more on what the rules prohibit, see fake reviews and the FTC rule.
Checklist
- Adopt a written review reply policy and train everyone who can post
- Limit reply access to one or two trained people
- Keep an approved template library for common complaints
- Apply the test: would this reply be true if they were never a patient?
- Audit old replies on every platform and remove any that disclose details
- Invite reviewers to contact the office, and handle it as a complaint
- Report policy violations instead of arguing in public
Frequently asked
Can we respond to reviews at all?
Yes. A calm, general reply shows prospective patients that you listen. What you cannot do is disclose anything about the person or their care, including confirming they were a patient. Keep replies short and move the conversation to a private channel.
The patient posted their own diagnosis. Can we mention it?
No. A patient's own post does not authorize you to discuss their care. Reply to the concern in general terms only, as if you did not know who wrote it.
Should we go back and fix old replies?
Yes. Read every reply your practice has posted on Google, Yelp, Healthgrades, Facebook and anywhere else, and remove or rewrite any that mention names, visits, conditions, insurance or billing. In the New Vision case, OCR required the practice to remove postings that disclosed patient information. Ask your compliance officer whether any disclosure needs further action.
Can we sue over a defamatory review?
Talk to an attorney before doing anything. The FTC says a legal threat is acceptable only when it has a legitimate basis, and any public dispute risks drawing more attention to the review. A short, professional reply and a steady flow of new reviews usually do more.
Do we need to reply to every review?
No. Prioritize negative reviews and reviews that raise a question other patients may share. A brief thank you on positive reviews is fine, as long as it confirms nothing about the reviewer's care.
Sources
- HHS Office for Civil Rights Reaches Agreement with Health Care Provider in New Jersey That Disclosed Patient Information in Response to Negative Online Reviews, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Manasa Health Center LLC Resolution Agreement and Corrective Action Plan, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- HHS Civil Rights Office Enters Settlement with Dental Practice Over Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- New Vision Dental Resolution Agreement and Corrective Action Plan, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Dental Practice Pays $10,000 to Settle Social Media Disclosures of Patients' Protected Health Information, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- Summary of the HIPAA Privacy Rule, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers, Federal Trade Commission
- Tips to get more reviews, Google Business Profile Help
- Report inappropriate reviews on your Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help
- Report negative review extortion scams on your Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help
- Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user generated content policy, Google Maps Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.