Fake reviews and the FTC rule
Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials has let the agency seek civil penalties for fake reviews, incentives tied to a positive rating, undisclosed reviews by managers and staff, and threats used to remove negative reviews. Your practice is also responsible for what marketing vendors do on its behalf.
What the rule prohibits, in practice terms
The FTC announced its final rule in August 2024, and FTC staff say it took effect on October 21, 2024. Here is what it covers, with examples of how each item could arise in a medical practice. The examples are hypothetical.
- Fake or false reviews and testimonials, including reviews written by AI or by someone who never used the service. Example: a marketing firm posts reviews from invented patients.
- Buying reviews that must be positive or negative. Example: a gift card offered for a five star review, stated or implied.
- Undisclosed insider reviews. Example: the office manager posts a glowing review without saying she works there.
- Company controlled review sites that claim to be independent. Example: a "best surgeons in the county" site secretly run by your practice that ranks you first.
- Review suppression through groundless legal threats, intimidation or certain false accusations, or by implying the reviews on your site are all of them when negative ones were filtered out.
- Fake social media indicators, such as bought followers or views.
This page is general information, not legal advice. Talk to a health care attorney about your specific situation.
Staff, family and friends
This is where practices most often stumble, because asking people close to you feels harmless.
Under the FTC rule, reviews by officers or managers that do not clearly disclose their connection to the business are prohibited, and there are requirements when managers solicit reviews from employees or relatives. The FTC's own questions and answers say a small business owner may ask family members to write reviews, but should ask them to clearly disclose the relationship.
Google is stricter. Its policy treats content based on a conflict of interest, including current or former employment and family relationships, as rating manipulation that is not allowed. So even a disclosed review from your spouse or your nurse does not belong on your Google profile.
The practical rule: staff and family do not review the practice on Google at all. If a staff member is also a patient, they should not review the practice either. Yelp's guidelines likewise say people should not review their employer or a relative's business.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Incentives: where the lines are
The FTC rule bans incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, whether the condition is stated or implied. FTC staff give an example of an implied condition: inviting customers to say how much they loved their visit in exchange for a coupon. Incentives that are not conditioned on sentiment are not banned by the rule itself, but FTC staff say failing to disclose them could still violate the FTC Act.
Google is again stricter. It prohibits offering payment, discounts, free goods or services in exchange for posting any review, regardless of sentiment, and in exchange for changing or removing a negative review.
For a practice, that adds up to a simple rule for Google reviews: no gift cards, no raffles, no discounts on the next visit, no free products, for any review. Thank patients for feedback in words only. If you are asking patients for reviews, the guide on asking for reviews without breaking HIPAA has a neutral template.
Your agency's tactics are your problem
The FTC's guide for marketers warns that some reputation management and search marketing companies get results by writing fake positive reviews of a business or fake negative reviews of its competitors, and that you can be held responsible for what they do on your behalf. It adds that review platforms could suspend or remove your accounts and listings.
Ask any agency or reputation vendor these questions in writing:
- Do you write, post or buy reviews, or use networks of reviewers?
- Do you ever post reviews from your own staff's accounts?
- Do you use review gating or sentiment routing?
- Do you offer patients anything for reviews?
- Will you confirm in our contract that you follow the FTC rule and each platform's policies?
Vague answers are an answer. For more warning signs, see agency red flags.
Suppression, and contracts that try to stop reviews
The rule's suppression provisions matter for practices that are tempted to fight back. FTC staff say you can respond publicly to a negative review, but you must not make accusations you know are false, use threats or intimidation to get it removed, or threaten legal action without a legitimate basis. Paying a patient to take down a truthful negative review may also violate the FTC Act.
A separate federal law, the Consumer Review Fairness Act, makes it illegal to use standard contract terms that bar or restrict customers from reviewing a business, penalize them for doing so, or claim rights in their review content. If your new patient paperwork contains anything that limits reviews, remove it. The FTC notes the law does allow removing reviews that contain confidential or private information, such as medical information, or that are clearly false or abusive.
For what to say instead, read responding to negative reviews without confirming someone is a patient.
How enforcement and detection work now
The FTC is using the rule. On December 22, 2025, it announced warning letters to 10 companies about possible violations, noting that the letters were not formal findings but that violations could lead to a federal lawsuit and civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation.
The platforms are watching too. Google says it blocked or removed more than 240 million policy violating reviews in 2024, uses AI to help detect fake reviews, and can now revisit reviews to find abuse patterns months after they were posted. When it determines a business has violated its fake engagement policy, Google says it may block new reviews, unpublish existing ones for a period, and display a warning to consumers that fake reviews were removed.
A fake review is therefore a lasting risk, not a one time shortcut. It can be found and acted on long after it was posted.
Checklist
- Confirm no staff, family or owners have reviewed the practice on Google
- Remove any incentive tied to reviews, including raffles and discounts
- Ask your agency in writing whether it writes, buys or gates reviews
- Add FTC rule and platform policy compliance to vendor contracts
- Remove any clause in patient paperwork that restricts reviews
- Never threaten a reviewer without legal advice and a legitimate basis
- If your site has a reviews section, do not filter out negative ones
Frequently asked
Can a staff member who is also a patient review the practice?
Not on Google. Its policy treats reviews from current or former employees as a conflict of interest. Under the FTC rule, insider reviews also raise disclosure requirements. The simplest policy is that staff do not review their own practice anywhere.
Is it fake if we write a review based on what a patient told us?
Yes. A review written by the practice misrepresents who wrote it, even if the sentiment came from a real patient. If a patient praises you in person, invite them to leave their own review in their own words, with no pressure and no suggested wording.
Can we help patients write reviews, or suggest wording?
No. Google's policy says merchants should not request that specific content be included in reviews, and drafting a review for a patient moves toward a review that does not reflect their own experience. Give them the link and let them write it.
What are the penalties under the FTC rule?
The rule lets the FTC seek civil penalties for knowing violations. The FTC's December 2025 warning letters cited civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. Platform consequences, such as removed reviews and profile restrictions, can also follow.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials, Federal Trade Commission
- The Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers, Federal Trade Commission
- FTC Warns 10 Companies About Possible Violations of the Agency's New Consumer Review Rule, Federal Trade Commission
- Soliciting and Paying for Online Reviews: A Guide for Marketers, Federal Trade Commission
- Consumer Review Fairness Act: What Businesses Need to Know, Federal Trade Commission
- Prohibited and restricted content, Maps user generated content policy, Google Maps Help
- Business Profile restrictions for policy violations, Google Business Profile Help
- Google Maps uses AI to fight fake Business Profiles, Google
- Content Guidelines, Yelp
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.