Testimonials and before and after photos: consent, FTC rules and state limits

Updated November 14, 2026 · 6 min read
Short answer

Before a patient's story, photo or video goes on your website, get a written HIPAA authorization that names the specific use, because publishing it identifies them as your patient. Then hold it to FTC rules: it must be real and honest, must not imply results most patients will not get, and must disclose any discount or perk the patient received. Your state medical board may add limits of its own.

Why a testimonial is a disclosure of patient information

A testimonial does more than praise your practice. It tells the world that a particular person was your patient, and often what you treated them for. Under HIPAA that is protected health information, and using it to promote your services is a marketing use that generally requires the patient's written authorization.

The authorization has required elements. It must describe the information specifically, name who will use or disclose it and who will receive it, state the purpose, give an expiration date or event, and carry the patient's signature and date. A line buried in your treatment consent form does not meet that standard.

Photos raise the stakes. HIPAA's list of identifiers includes full face photographs and any comparable images, along with any other unique identifying characteristic. A cropped photo that shows a distinctive tattoo or birthmark can still identify someone. Treat every patient image as identifying unless your attorney tells you otherwise.

The same logic applies to replies to online reviews. Confirming in public that a reviewer was seen at your office is a disclosure, which is why responding to negative reviews needs its own approach.

A consent process that holds up

Build a process before you build a testimonials page.

  1. Use a separate, written authorization for marketing, not your general treatment consent.
  2. List exactly what you will publish: the quote, the specific photos or the video, and whether the patient's name or initials appear.
  3. List where it will appear: your website, social media, ads, printed materials.
  4. Give an expiration date or event, and explain that the patient can revoke the authorization in writing at any time. HIPAA gives patients that right, except to the extent you have already acted on it.
  5. For minors and others with a personal representative, get the representative's signature and document their authority.
  6. Store the signed form with the patient's record and keep a log of every place the material is used, so you can remove it quickly if the patient changes their mind.

Be careful with incentives. A free treatment or discount in exchange for a testimonial is a material connection that the FTC expects you to disclose, and your state board may have its own view on it.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

FTC rules: real, honest, typical and disclosed

The FTC's Endorsement Guides, revised in 2023, treat a patient testimonial as a claim by your practice. If a testimonial says a treatment worked, you need the same evidence you would need to say it yourself, and the FTC's health products guidance says individual experiences, even surveys of them, are never sufficient on their own to substantiate claims about a health product's effects.

If a patient's results are better than what patients generally achieve, the ad should clearly disclose the generally expected results. A small "results not typical" line does not do that job. Material connections must be disclosed clearly: staff, their relatives, and patients who received anything of value for the testimonial.

The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, adopted in August 2024, adds direct prohibitions. A business may not write, create or sell a testimonial that misrepresents that the person exists or had the experience described. It may not offer compensation or incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment. Testimonials by officers, managers, employees or agents need a clear disclosure of the relationship when it is not otherwise obvious. And a site's review section must not suggest it shows most or all reviews while hiding the negative ones. See fake reviews and the FTC rule for the review side.

Before and after photos that do not mislead

Before and after photos are the most persuasive content on many aesthetic, dermatology and surgical sites, which is why regulators look at them closely. The FSMB's position is that patient testimonials and similar material must be presented objectively and must not misrepresent the expected outcomes of treatment.

Practical rules that keep a gallery honest:

  • Same lighting, angle, distance, pose and background in both photos
  • No makeup, filters or retouching on the after photo that was not on the before
  • Label each set with the treatment, the number of sessions and the time since treatment
  • Say so if the result came from more than one procedure
  • Show a representative range of results, not only your best cases
  • Get a written authorization for every set, even if the face is not shown

A hypothetical example of what to avoid: a laser clinic posts an after photo taken under a ring light with makeup, next to a before photo taken under fluorescent exam room light. The difference is real, but much of it is the lighting.

State medical board rules

Your state medical board, and boards for other licensed professionals on your team, can treat misleading advertising as a professional conduct issue, which puts your license in play rather than just your marketing budget. The Federation of State Medical Boards' position statement on physician advertising says physicians may advertise as long as the ads contain no deceptive or intentionally false or misleading claims, that testimonials and ratings must be presented objectively, and that physicians should be ready to support claims with documented evidence.

Each state writes its own rules, and they can differ from what the FTC requires on points such as testimonials, photographs and claims about outcomes. Before you publish a testimonials page or a gallery, ask your healthcare attorney to check it against your state's current rules. Claims about what treatments do are covered in more depth in health claims: FTC and state medical board limits.

What to do this week

Pull up every testimonial, patient photo, patient video and embedded review on your site and social accounts, and ask four questions about each one. Do we have a signed authorization that covers this use? Does it reflect what patients generally experience, or is it an outlier? Did the patient receive anything of value? Is the patient an employee or relative of someone here?

Take down anything you cannot answer, then rebuild with consent forms and labeling in place. It is far easier to add a testimonial later than to explain one you never had permission to use. For showing reviews on your site the right way, see reviews on your website.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. Have your healthcare attorney review your authorization form and your testimonials page before you publish.

Checklist

  • A signed marketing authorization is on file for every testimonial, photo and video
  • Each authorization lists the specific material, where it will appear and when it expires
  • Patients know they can revoke consent in writing, and you can remove material quickly
  • Results that are better than typical carry a clear statement of generally expected results
  • Any perk, discount or relationship behind a testimonial is clearly disclosed
  • Before and after photos match on lighting, angle and pose, and are labeled with treatment and timing
  • Your attorney has checked the page against your state's advertising rules

Frequently asked

Can we repost a patient's public Google review on our website?

Treat it like any other testimonial. The patient wrote it publicly, but your practice republishing it in your own marketing confirms the relationship and uses it to promote your services. The safer course is a written authorization, plus an honest selection that does not show only the best reviews. Ask your attorney.

Can we offer a discount in exchange for a testimonial?

The FTC rule bars incentives conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, and any incentive is a material connection that must be clearly disclosed. Your state board may restrict it further. Avoiding incentives altogether is the simplest way to keep a testimonial clean.

Do we need consent if the patient's face is not shown?

Assume yes. HIPAA's identifiers include comparable images and any unique identifying characteristic, and a photo of a known patient's body, tattoo or surroundings can identify them. Patients also expect to be asked. Get a written authorization for every image.

Can our staff post testimonials about the practice?

Only with a clear disclosure of their relationship to the practice when it is not obvious to readers. The FTC's reviews rule addresses testimonials by officers, managers, employees and agents, and reviews written by staff posing as patients are fake reviews.

Sources

  1. 45 CFR 164.508, Uses and disclosures for which an authorization is required (marketing, core elements, revocation), Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  2. 45 CFR 164.514, list of identifiers including full face photographic images, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  3. 16 CFR Part 255, Guides Concerning Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  4. FTC's Endorsement Guides, Federal Trade Commission
  5. 16 CFR 465.2, Fake or false consumer reviews, consumer testimonials, or celebrity testimonials, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  6. 16 CFR 465.4, Buying positive or negative consumer reviews, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  7. 16 CFR 465.5, Insider consumer reviews and consumer testimonials, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  8. 16 CFR 465.7, Review suppression, Electronic Code of Federal Regulations
  9. Health Products Compliance Guidance, Federal Trade Commission
  10. Position Statement on Sale of Goods by Physicians and Physician Advertising (April 2016), Federation of State Medical Boards
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.