Agency red flags

Updated November 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Short answer

Be cautious with any vendor that guarantees rankings, keeps your domain or Google accounts in its own name, will not explain how results are measured, offers to manufacture or filter reviews, puts tracking on patient pages without a business associate agreement, or locks you into a contract with no way out. One red flag is a question to ask, not proof, and the list applies to us too.

A red flag is a question, not a verdict

Most practices hire marketing help without the background to judge the work. That is normal; you hire a vendor because they know things you do not. It also means you need a few reliable signals that something is off.

The red flags below are behaviors and promises, not companies. Any vendor can show one, including good ones having a bad day, and including us. When you see one, ask about it directly and in writing. A good vendor will give you a clear answer. A vendor who becomes evasive has told you something useful.

Google publishes its own short list of warning signs when hiring help with search. Several of the items below come straight from it.

Promises no one can keep

  • Guaranteed rankings. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. A guarantee is either a misunderstanding or a sales tactic.
  • A special relationship with Google. Google warns against vendors who claim a special relationship or offer priority submission to Google. There is no such thing for organic or map results.
  • Fixed new patient numbers by a date. New patients depend on your phones, schedule, insurance mix and reputation, none of which an agency controls. Honest vendors set expectations, not guarantees.
  • Instant results. Fixing a broken listing can show results quickly. Building search visibility for a new service usually takes months.
  • Secret methods. Google lists secretive practices, and vendors unwilling to explain what they do, as warning signs. You should be able to understand, in plain language, what is being done to your site and listings.

What to ask instead: what will you do in the first ninety days, how will we measure it, and what would make you tell us it is not working?

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

Control red flags

These are about who holds your assets, and they are the most expensive to discover late.

  • The domain is registered in the vendor's name. You should be the registrant. See your agency owns your domain, not you.
  • You cannot get an administrator login to your own website, Google Analytics, Search Console or ad accounts.
  • The vendor is primary owner of your Google Business Profile and offers you nothing more than manager access.
  • Tracking numbers replace your main number on your profile and directories, with no right to port them if you leave.
  • Reports arrive as screenshots or PDFs only, with no access to the accounts behind them.
  • Content is licensed, not owned, with no exception for the pages written about your practice.

What to ask instead: put ownership of the domain, content and accounts in the contract, as described in who owns your domain, hosting and content.

Shortcuts that break the rules

Some tactics work briefly and then cost you. A vendor who suggests them is putting your practice's reputation at risk.

  • Fake or bought reviews. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews and testimonials, announced in August 2024, prohibits creating or buying fake reviews, including AI generated ones, and offering compensation conditioned on a review expressing a particular sentiment, and allows the FTC to seek civil penalties against knowing violators.
  • Review gating. Google's policy for Maps content prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews or discouraging negative ones, and offering incentives in exchange for reviews. A tool that sends only happy patients to Google crosses that line. See review gating: why it breaks Google's rules.
  • Keyword stuffed business names. Google's guidelines say your profile name should be your real world name, without added keywords or locations.
  • Fake locations. Profiles at virtual offices or addresses where you do not see patients break Google's rules.
  • Link schemes and mass directory submissions. Google's own list of warning signs includes promoting link popularity schemes and submitting your site to many search engines.

Patient privacy red flags

In healthcare, a careless marketing setup can expose patient information. Watch for:

  • Advertising pixels or tracking on booking, intake or portal pages, without a clear compliance review
  • No business associate agreement from a vendor whose tools receive information patients type, such as forms, chat or call recordings
  • Dismissing HIPAA as not our area, when the vendor is the one installing the scripts
  • Patient stories or photos used in marketing without written permission from the patient
  • Remarketing audiences built from visits to pages about specific conditions, without any review of whether that is appropriate

What to ask instead: which tools touch patient information, which vendors will sign business associate agreements, and which pages carry tracking. More in HIPAA safe analytics. This is general information, not legal advice.

Contract and reporting red flags

Finally, the paperwork.

  • A long minimum term with automatic renewal and a short window to cancel
  • The website disappears when you stop paying, with no option to buy it out
  • Ad spend and management fees blended together, so you cannot see what reached the ad platform
  • Reports without outcomes, full of impressions and rankings but no inquiries or new patients
  • A different set of metrics every month, so trends never show
  • No named contact, or slow answers when something patient facing breaks

None of these is automatically disqualifying. Some practices accept a longer term in exchange for a lower build cost, for example. But each should be visible and agreed, not discovered at renewal.

Checklist

  • No guaranteed rankings or claimed special relationship with Google
  • Domain, content and Google accounts owned by the practice in writing
  • Administrator access to the website, analytics, Search Console and ad accounts
  • No fake, bought, incentivized or gated reviews
  • Business associate agreements for every tool that receives patient information
  • Ad spend shown separately from management fees
  • Monthly reports that lead with inquiries and new patients

Frequently asked

Is a ranking guarantee always a red flag?

Yes. Google says no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. A vendor can reasonably commit to work, timelines and measures, but not to a position that depends on Google, competitors and where each patient searches from.

Our agency asks happy patients for Google reviews and unhappy ones for private feedback. Is that a problem?

It can be. Google's policy prohibits selectively soliciting positive reviews or discouraging negative ones. The safer approach is to invite every patient to review, without filtering by how they feel. If you also collect private feedback, do not use it to decide who gets asked for a public review.

What should we do if we spot a red flag in our current vendor?

Ask about it in writing and give them a chance to answer. If the issue is ownership or access, ask for the change now. If the answer is unsatisfactory, plan your exit carefully, starting with securing access, as described in our guide to leaving your agency.

Does this list apply to you?

Yes. We are a vendor too. Every red flag and every question in this series applies to us exactly as it applies to anyone else, and we would rather you ask than assume.

Sources

  1. Do you need an SEO?, Google Search Central
  2. Federal Trade Commission Announces Final Rule Banning Fake Reviews and Testimonials, Federal Trade Commission
  3. Prohibited & restricted content, Maps User Generated Content Policy Help
  4. Guidelines for representing your business on Google, Google Business Profile Help
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.