Your agency owns your domain, not you

Updated November 14, 2026 · 4 min read
Short answer

If your marketing agency registered your practice's domain in its own name or account, it controls your web address, your email and years of search history, and leaving can mean starting over. Check who the registrant is today, and move the domain into an account your practice owns while the relationship is still friendly.

Why the domain is the asset that matters

Your domain is the address on your business cards, referral pads, signage, Google Business Profile, insurer directories and every link anyone has ever made to your site. It is also, in most practices, the address your email runs on.

A website can be rebuilt in weeks. A domain with years of history cannot be replaced. If someone else controls it, they can decide whether it renews, where it points and whether your email keeps working. Most agencies would never misuse that control. But practices find out who really holds the domain at the worst possible moment: during a billing dispute, after the agency is sold, or when the one person who knew the login has left.

How it ends up in the agency's name

It is rarely sinister. Usually it happens like this:

  • At launch, the agency "handled everything" and registered the domain in its own reseller account for convenience
  • The registrant contact is an agency employee or a generic agency email address
  • A former office manager registered it with a personal email and a personal credit card
  • A partner who has since left the practice set it up years ago
  • The domain was bundled into a hosting package, and nobody separated the two

In every one of these cases, the practice uses the domain every day without controlling it.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

Check who owns it in ten minutes

  1. Look up your domain using ICANN's public lookup tool or your registrar's own lookup. You will see the registrar, the company where the domain is registered, and the expiry date. Registrant details are often hidden for privacy, which is normal.
  2. Find out who has the login for that registrar account. If nobody at the practice does, that is your answer.
  3. If you can log in, check that the registrant organization is your practice's legal entity and that the contact email is a shared practice address you control, not a person's personal email.
  4. Check the expiry date and turn on automatic renewal with a current payment method.
  5. Check who can change the DNS settings, which control where your website and email point.

ICANN's registrant guidance says registrants must provide accurate contact information and keep their registrar account data current. If the account is not yours, you cannot meet that responsibility.

Moving it into your name

Ask your agency in writing, politely and specifically. Most will cooperate, especially if you ask while the relationship is good.

  1. Create an account at a registrar in your practice's name, using a shared practice email address and two factor authentication.
  2. Ask the agency either to move the domain into your account, if you will use the same registrar, or to give you the transfer code, sometimes called an auth code, so you can transfer it to your registrar. ICANN's transfer rules require the registrar to provide this code to the registrant on request.
  3. Confirm the registrant name and contact details are your practice's.
  4. Leave the DNS settings exactly as they are until the move is complete, so your website and email keep working.
  5. Turn on the registrar lock and automatic renewal, and store the login in your practice's password manager.

One caution: registrars can block transfers for a period after a domain is newly registered, recently transferred or has its registrant details changed. Plan the move well before any deadline, such as the end of a contract.

The domain is not the only thing to own

While you are at it, make a list of every account your online presence depends on, and confirm your practice is the owner, with the agency added as a user rather than the other way around:

  • Website hosting, and a recent full backup of the site
  • DNS, if it is managed somewhere other than the registrar
  • Google Business Profile, with a practice owner on every location
  • Google Analytics, Search Console, Tag Manager and any ad accounts
  • Social media accounts
  • Call tracking numbers, and whether they can be moved if you leave
  • Photo and video files, with licenses for any images the agency bought

For a full ownership audit, see who owns your domain, hosting and content.

Put it in the contract

The best time to settle ownership is before work starts. Whether you are signing with a new agency or renewing with your current one, the agreement should say:

  • The domain is registered to the practice, in a practice owned account
  • The practice owns its content, photos and data, and receives copies on request
  • The agency will hand over all logins and transfer codes within a set number of days of ending the relationship
  • No fees apply to release your own assets

If an agency resists those terms, treat it as a warning sign. See agency red flags, long contracts and what they hide and leaving your agency without losing your rankings.

Checklist

  • You know which registrar holds your domain and when it expires
  • Someone at the practice can log in to the registrar account
  • The registrant is your practice, with a shared practice email address
  • Automatic renewal and the registrar lock are on
  • Your Google Business Profile, analytics and ad accounts are owned by the practice
  • Logins live in a practice password manager, not one person's memory
  • Your agency contract says the practice owns its domain and content

Frequently asked

What happens if our domain expires?

Your website and email can stop working, and if it is not renewed in time, the domain can eventually be lost and registered by someone else. Automatic renewal with a current payment method, in an account you control, prevents this.

Our agency says it is easier if they keep the domain. Is that true?

It may be convenient for them, but you can give the agency access to manage DNS from your own account. That keeps the work just as easy while ownership stays with the practice.

Will moving the domain take our website or email offline?

It should not, if the DNS settings stay the same during the move. Ask whoever runs your website and email to confirm the settings before and after, and plan the move for a quiet time rather than a busy clinic morning.

What if the agency will not cooperate?

Ask in writing, keep records, and check your contract. If the domain was registered by a former employee or partner, they may be able to authorize the change. If the dispute continues, speak with an attorney; this is general information, not legal advice.

Sources

  1. FAQs for Registrants: Transferring Your Domain Name, ICANN
  2. Registrants' Benefits and Responsibilities, ICANN
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.