Leaving your agency without losing your rankings

Updated November 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Short answer

Secure access to everything before you give notice: the domain, DNS, hosting, website login, Google Business Profile, Analytics, Search Console, ad accounts and call tracking. Then move one thing at a time, keep the domain the same if you can, redirect every old page that changes address, and watch your search and call data closely for the following months.

Before you give notice: secure access

The worst time to discover that your agency holds your accounts is the day after you tell them you are leaving. Even a vendor acting in good faith can be slow when they are losing a client, and some access changes have waiting periods built in.

So do this first, quietly and politely, as a normal housekeeping request:

  1. Ask for owner or administrator access to every account listed below, for a practice controlled account.
  2. Confirm the practice is the domain registrant and can log in to the registrar.
  3. Download a full copy of the website's content and images.
  4. Export the reports and data you want to keep: analytics, call logs, ad history.

One waiting period matters especially. Google says new Business Profile owners and managers must wait seven days before they can do some things, including transferring primary ownership. Start early so the clock has run before you need it.

Inventory what they control

Make a list with three columns: the asset, who owns it today, and who will own it after the move.

  • Domain registration and registrar account
  • DNS, including the records that run your email
  • Website hosting and the content management system
  • Website content, images and any licensed fonts or stock photos
  • Google Business Profile for each location and provider
  • Google Analytics property
  • Search Console property
  • Google Ads and any other ad accounts
  • Call tracking numbers, and every place those numbers appear
  • Online booking, forms and chat tools, and their business associate agreements
  • Social media accounts and directory listings the agency claimed

Everything on the list should end up owned by the practice, with the new vendor given access. See who owns your domain, hosting and content.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

The domain, DNS and email

Keep the same domain if you possibly can. Changing domains is a site move in Google's eyes and adds risk; changing vendors does not require it.

If the domain itself must move to a different registrar, ICANN's Transfer Policy sets the rules. Registrars must give the registrant the authorization code and remove the transfer lock within five calendar days of the request, if the registrar does not let you generate the code yourself. Registrars may deny a transfer within 60 days of the domain's creation or a previous transfer, and must impose a 60 day transfer lock after a change of registrant unless the registrant opted out beforehand. ICANN's board adopted revisions to the transfer rules in June 2026, which are being implemented, so ask your registrar which rules apply to your domain at the time.

The bigger risk is often email. If the agency manages your DNS, moving the website can break your email if someone forgets the mail records. Before any DNS change, export the current records, and test email immediately afterward.

The Google accounts

Each Google account has its own handover.

  • Business Profile: only the primary owner can transfer primary ownership. Once the practice account has been an owner for seven days, the agency, or whoever is primary owner, can transfer it. Google says transferring primary ownership keeps your business information and reviews. Then remove the agency or reduce it to manager.
  • Google Analytics: make sure a practice account has the Administrator role, which can manage users. Then remove the old agency's access.
  • Search Console: add the practice as a verified owner, ideally through a DNS record on a domain property, then remove the agency's verification.
  • Ad accounts: if the agency controls the account, ask for a practice login with the highest access level the platform offers before the agency's access is removed, or at minimum for full exports of the campaign history.

Do not delete and recreate any of these. A new Business Profile, analytics property or ad account starts with no history.

If the site itself is changing: redirects

If the new vendor rebuilds the site, the page addresses will probably change. This is where most rankings are lost.

Google's guidance on site moves recommends:

  • Mapping every old address to its new address before launch
  • Using server side permanent redirects, such as 301 or 308
  • Keeping redirects as long as possible, generally at least one year
  • Updating internal links and submitting an updated sitemap
  • Keeping control of the old domain if the domain changes, so the redirects keep working

Google also says that for a medium sized site it can take a few weeks or more for the new addresses to replace the old ones in results, so some fluctuation is expected. Read redirects: the step that saves your traffic before the new site goes live, and keep the old site available until the redirects are checked.

The first ninety days after

Watch closely, because problems are cheapest to fix early.

  • Week one: test every booking button, phone link and form on the new site. Check email. Check that analytics records visits and key events.
  • Weeks one to four: in Search Console, watch clicks and the page indexing report for important pages. Test old addresses to confirm they redirect to the right new pages, not the homepage.
  • Monthly: compare clicks, Business Profile calls and new patient inquiries with the same month last year.
  • Call tracking: if the old agency's tracking numbers appeared in listings or print, check that they still forward, or replace them with your main number before forwarding ends.

If something drops and stays down after a few weeks, look for missing redirects, pages that were removed or merged, and blocked crawling before assuming the worst. See the SEO safe redesign checklist.

Checklist

  • Owner or administrator access to every account secured before giving notice
  • The practice confirmed as domain registrant with registrar login
  • A full content and image export saved by the practice
  • DNS records exported before any change, and email tested after
  • Business Profile primary ownership transferred to a practice account
  • Every changed page address mapped and permanently redirected
  • Search Console and call data checked weekly for the first month

Frequently asked

Will we lose our Google rankings if we change agencies?

Not necessarily. Changing who manages your site does not affect rankings by itself. Rankings are lost when page addresses change without redirects, pages are removed, or the domain changes. Keep the domain, redirect every changed address and monitor Search Console.

How long does it take to move a domain to our own account?

Changing the registrant within the same registrar can be quick. Moving to a different registrar depends on ICANN's rules: the current registrar must provide the authorization code within five calendar days of your request, and transfer locks of up to 60 days can apply after a registration, a previous transfer or a change of registrant.

Our agency is primary owner of our Google profile and will not respond. What can we do?

You can request ownership through Google. The current owner is notified and has three days to respond, and if they do not, you may be able to claim the profile by verifying the business. Keep records of your requests.

Should the new site launch the same day we leave the old agency?

Avoid it if you can. Secure access first, move accounts next, and launch the new site only when redirects are mapped and tested. Overlapping the old vendor's contract by a few weeks is often cheaper than a rushed launch.

Sources

  1. Manage your Business Profile owners & managers, Google Business Profile Help
  2. Transfer primary ownership of a Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help
  3. Request ownership of a Business Profile, Google Business Profile Help
  4. Transfer Policy, ICANN
  5. Approved Resolutions, Regular Meeting of the ICANN Board, 7 June 2026, ICANN
  6. Site moves with URL changes, Google Search Central
  7. Access and data restriction management (roles), Google Analytics Help
  8. Verify your site ownership, Search Console Help
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.