Redirects: the step that saves your traffic in a redesign
A permanent redirect sends patients and Google from an old page address to its new one, and tells Google to rank the new address in its place. When a redesign changes addresses, every old page that earned traffic needs a server side 301 redirect to its closest new match, kept in place for at least a year and ideally for good.
What a redirect does, in plain English
Every page on your site has an address, such as yourpractice.com/services/cataract-surgery. Google has that exact address stored, other websites link to it, and a patient may have it bookmarked. If your new site moves the page to yourpractice.com/cataract-surgery, the old address becomes a dead end unless you leave a forwarding instruction behind.
That instruction is a redirect. Google describes two kinds:
- Permanent redirects, status codes 301 and 308, tell Google the move is for good. Google shows the new address in results and treats it as the main version.
- Temporary redirects, codes 302 and 307, tell Google to follow the link for now but keep treating the old address as the real one.
For a redesign, you want permanent redirects, set up on the server. Google recommends server side permanent redirects whenever possible and treats JavaScript redirects as a last resort, because they only work if Google successfully renders the page.
Build the redirect map in a spreadsheet
The redirect map is a simple spreadsheet, and it is the most important document in a redesign. Make one row per old address with four columns: old address, new address, redirect type, and tested result.
Fill the old address column from your current sitemap, your content system's page list, your Search Console Performance report and your analytics landing pages. Google suggests starting with the important addresses from exactly these places. Do not forget:
- PDFs such as new patient packets and consent forms
- Old provider pages, including providers who have left
- Location pages and any old campaign landing pages
- Blog posts, even old ones, since some still bring in searches
Then give each one the closest match on the new site. An old page on acne treatment goes to the new acne page. An old bio at /dr-smith goes to /providers/jane-smith-md. A retired service with no replacement gets no redirect at all, which brings us to the most common mistake.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Redirect to the closest match, not the homepage
The tempting shortcut is to send every old address to the homepage. It feels safe, because nothing shows an error. Google says not to do it: redirecting many old addresses to one unrelated page such as the homepage can confuse users and may be treated as a soft 404, an error page in disguise. The ranking that page earned does not transfer.
The patient experience is just as bad. Someone who clicked a search result for "sciatica treatment" and lands on your homepage has to start over, and many will not.
For content you are truly dropping, Google's advice is to let the old address return a 404 or 410 status. That is an honest answer, and Google will drop the page from results over time. If there is a related page that genuinely answers the same need, such as a general spine page for a retired sciatica page, redirect there instead. Make the call page by page, and record it in the map.
Mistakes that quietly break redirects
Redirects fail silently. Look for these:
- Chains. Old address to an older redirect to the new page. Google suggests keeping chains under three to five hops and notes that Googlebot follows at most ten. After each redesign, update old redirects to point straight to the final page.
- Temporary instead of permanent. Some platforms default to 302. Check the status code, not just that the page arrives.
- Missing variations. The old site may be reachable with and without www, on http and https, and with or without a trailing slash. Each needs to land on the new page.
- Redirects left behind on the old host. If you change platforms, redirects stored in the old platform's settings disappear when you cancel it.
- A lapsed old domain. If you moved domains, let the old one expire and every redirect stops working, and someone else can buy it.
Each of these looks fine to a person clicking around, which is why you test with a tool, as described below. More on this failure in a redesign that wiped out your rankings.
How long to keep redirects
Google's guidance for site moves is to keep redirects for as long as possible, and generally for at least one year. If you are changing domains and use Search Console's Change of Address tool, Google asks you to keep redirects for at least 180 days, and longer if they still receive traffic.
Our advice is simpler: keep them forever. Redirects cost almost nothing to keep, and old links on hospital directories, referral pages and patient emails keep working for years. Keep your old domain registered and renewing automatically, in the practice's name. If you are moving to a new agency at the same time, make sure the redirects live in a place you control, as covered in leaving your agency without losing your rankings.
How to test your redirects
Test before launch on staging if your developer can, and again in the first hour after launch.
- Paste a sample of old addresses from your spreadsheet into a bulk redirect checker or a site crawler in list mode. Most will show the status code and the final destination for each.
- Confirm each one returns 301 or 308, lands on the planned new page, and that page returns a normal 200 status.
- Fix any row that lands on the homepage by mistake, loops, or chains through more than one hop.
- For your most important pages, use the URL Inspection tool in Search Console to check how Google sees the new address.
- Over the next weeks, watch the Page indexing report. Old addresses showing up as "Page with redirect" is expected. A rise in "Not found (404)" is a sign that rows are missing from your map.
Record the tested result in the spreadsheet. If a page ever goes missing later, that column tells you whether it was tested. If you are changing platforms too, see switching platforms without losing patients.
Checklist
- Every old address that earned traffic has its own row in the redirect map
- Each row points to the closest matching new page, never the homepage by default
- Redirects are permanent (301 or 308) and set up on the server
- Retired pages with no equivalent return a 404 or 410
- Old redirect chains now point straight to the final page
- www, non www, http and https versions all land on the right page
- The old domain is still registered to the practice and set to auto renew
Frequently asked
Will I still lose rankings if I set up redirects?
Some short term movement is normal while Google recrawls. Google says it can take a few weeks or more for a medium sized site's new addresses to replace the old ones. With a complete map of permanent redirects, rankings should settle as Google transfers its signals to the new addresses.
My website builder only offers a redirect settings page. Is that good enough?
Usually, yes, as long as it returns a real 301 status from the server. Check a few addresses with a redirect checker after setup. The problem to avoid is a redirect done with a script on the page, which Google may miss.
Do I need redirects for pages that get almost no traffic?
Map them anyway if there is a sensible new page. Low traffic pages may still have links from other sites or patient emails, and a redirect costs nothing. If there is no sensible match, let the address return a 404.
What is the difference between a redirect and a canonical tag?
A redirect physically sends visitors to another address. A canonical tag leaves the page in place and tells Google which version to rank when duplicates exist. Redesigns need redirects for moved pages, and every new page should carry a canonical tag pointing to itself.
Sources
- Redirects and Google Search, Google Search Central
- Site moves with URL changes, Google Search Central
- Change of Address tool, Google Search Console Help
- How HTTP status codes and network errors affect Google Search, Google Search Central
- Page indexing report, Google Search Console Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.