No clear path for new patients

Updated November 14, 2026 · 4 min read
Short answer

New patients arrive with questions existing patients never ask: are you taking new patients, do you accept my insurance, do I need a referral, and what happens at the first visit. If your site makes them hunt for those answers, many give up. Build one clear New Patients page and link to it from the header of every page.

Two kinds of visitors, one confusing homepage

Existing patients come to your site to log in to the portal, request a refill, pay a bill or check the hours. New patients come to decide whether you are the right practice and how to get in. Most practice homepages try to serve both at once and end up serving neither well.

A new patient who sees "Patient Portal", "Pay Your Bill" and "Request Records" across the top of the page reasonably concludes the site is not for them. Give them their own door. In the header, put a clear "New patients" link next to the booking button, and keep the portal link separate. See new patient versus existing patient calls to action and the patient portal login nobody can find.

The questions a new patient needs answered before booking

Put yourself in the shoes of someone who has never been to your office. Before they commit, they want to know:

  • Are you accepting new patients, and with which providers?
  • Do you take my insurance, and what if I am paying myself?
  • Do I need a referral, and how do I get my records to you?
  • Which provider or visit type should I choose?
  • How soon can I be seen?
  • What should I bring: ID, insurance card, medication list, imaging?
  • Are there forms to complete before the visit, and can I do them online?
  • Where do I park, and which entrance do I use?
  • How long will the first visit take?

If any of those answers requires a phone call during business hours, you will lose some patients who would have booked tonight.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

What a good New Patients page looks like

One page, in the order patients think, with a booking button at the top and again at the bottom:

  1. A plain statement of whether you are accepting new patients, and any limits, such as "accepting new patients ages 18 and up with Dr. Rivera and Dr. Chen"
  2. A short insurance summary, linking to the full insurance page
  3. Referral rules, explained by situation, such as which plans require one
  4. How to book, with the button, the phone number and what to expect if they request instead of book
  5. What to bring and which forms to complete in advance, with links to online versions
  6. What happens at the first visit, step by step
  7. Directions, parking and the entrance to use

Keep it scannable on a phone. Short headings, short paragraphs and lists. See insurance accepted pages for the page it should link to.

Walk the path yourself

Test it the way a new patient would, on a phone.

  1. Search for your specialty and your town, and tap your practice in the results.
  2. From the page you land on, find new patient information. Count the taps.
  3. Find whether you take a specific insurance plan.
  4. Find out whether you need a referral.
  5. Book, or get as far as you can.
  6. Find the forms you would need to complete before arriving.

Better still, ask a friend who has never used your site to do it while you watch without helping. Note every place they pause, scroll back or say "hmm". Those are the spots where real patients leave.

Specialty wrinkles

The basic page works for everyone, but some practices need extra pieces. These are hypothetical patterns, not rules:

  • Referral based specialties. Explain which insurance plans require a referral and offer a way for patients or referring offices to send records and imaging before the visit.
  • Primary care. Accepting status often differs by provider. Keep it accurate per provider and update it the same day it changes.
  • Pediatrics. Expectant parents often choose a pediatrician before the baby arrives. Offer a meet the doctor option and explain newborn visits.
  • Behavioral health. Many practices start with a screening call or intake form. Say so, explain what happens, and tell patients how soon they will hear back.
  • Cosmetic and self pay services. Explain consultation fees and what the consult includes, so nobody is surprised.

Say it where Google and AI can read it

A simple sentence on your homepage and New Patients page, such as "We are accepting new patients at both our Elm Street and Oak Avenue offices", is easy for a patient to trust and easy for an AI assistant to repeat when someone asks who is taking new patients nearby.

For search engines, schema.org's vocabulary includes an isAcceptingNewPatients property for medical organizations, including the MedicalClinic type. Ask your developer to include it in your structured data, and keep it accurate. Then carry the experience past the booking: send forms, directions and what to expect before the first visit. More in new patient onboarding online.

Checklist

  • A New Patients link sits in the header of every page
  • The New Patients page states clearly whether you are accepting new patients
  • Insurance, referral rules and self pay options are explained
  • New patients can book or request a visit without calling
  • Forms are available online before the first visit
  • Directions, parking and the entrance are described
  • Someone outside the practice has tested the path on a phone

Frequently asked

Should the New Patients page replace our homepage booking button?

No. Keep the booking button in the header for patients who are ready, and add a New Patients link for those who need answers first. Both should be visible on a phone without scrolling.

What if only some providers are accepting new patients?

Say exactly that, by name, and keep it current. Make the booking tool show only providers who are accepting new patients, so a patient never books a visit you will have to cancel.

Should we put forms on the New Patients page as PDFs?

Online forms that patients can complete on a phone work better than PDFs that need printing. If you must use PDFs, make them fillable on screen and accessible, and tell patients how to return them.

How do we explain referral requirements without giving insurance advice?

Explain your practice's process, such as "Some HMO plans require a referral from your primary care doctor before your visit", and tell patients to check with their plan or call your office if unsure. Avoid promising coverage.

Sources

  1. MedicalClinic, Schema.org
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.