Tracking pixels on pages where patients enter health information
If an advertising or analytics tag sits on your booking pages, forms, symptom tools or patient portal login, it can send what patients type or select to that company, and HHS treats that as a disclosure of protected health information. A 2024 court ruling struck down part of HHS's guidance, but not the part about pages where patients enter health information or log in.
What a tracking pixel does
A tracking pixel is a small piece of code from an advertising or analytics company. When a page loads, or when a visitor clicks or submits something, it sends information back to that company: the page address, the visitor's IP address, device identifiers, and sometimes the buttons pressed or values typed into a form. Advertisers use it to measure ads and to build audiences for retargeting.
HHS's bulletin on the subject describes the family broadly: cookies, web beacons or tracking pixels, session replay scripts and fingerprinting scripts. On practice websites they usually arrive in one of three ways. An agency added them to run ads. A plugin or theme included them by default. Or a third party tool, such as a booking or chat widget, carries its own.
Most practices that have them do not know exactly which ones they have or what they send.
Where the rules stand in November 2026
This is a summary of public documents, not legal advice. Talk to your privacy counsel before changing anything with legal consequences.
- December 2022. HHS's Office for Civil Rights issued a bulletin on how HIPAA applies to online tracking technologies used by covered entities such as medical practices.
- March 18, 2024. HHS issued a revised version of the bulletin.
- June 20, 2024. In American Hospital Association v. Becerra, a federal court in the Northern District of Texas declared unlawful and vacated one part of the revised bulletin: the position that HIPAA obligations are triggered when tracking technology connects an individual's IP address with a visit to an unauthenticated public webpage addressing specific health conditions or health care providers. The court denied a permanent injunction.
The HHS bulletin page now opens with a notice describing that ruling. The rest of the bulletin remains on HHS's site. It says tracking on logged in pages such as patient portals generally has access to protected health information. It says tracking on public pages where people schedule appointments or use a symptom checker may have access to it, for example the reason for the visit a patient types or selects. It treats information entered on a portal login or registration page as covered. And it says a tracking vendor that receives protected health information is a business associate, which requires a business associate agreement.
The HIPAA rules themselves did not change. State privacy laws may add their own requirements.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Pages to check first
Start with the pages where patients tell you something about their health:
- Online booking pages and embedded booking widgets, especially if the visit type or reason is chosen on the page
- Appointment request, contact and new patient forms
- Symptom checkers, quizzes and "am I a candidate" tools
- Patient portal login and registration pages
- Bill pay and telehealth pages
- Thank you and confirmation pages, particularly when the page address includes the service booked
- Chat widgets that ask why the patient is visiting
Be more conservative on condition and service pages for sensitive specialties, such as behavioral health, reproductive health, addiction treatment and infectious disease. Even where the law is unsettled, patients reasonably expect that browsing those pages is private.
How to see what is on your site
You do not need to be technical to start.
- Ask your agency or web developer, in writing, for a list of every tag, pixel and script on the site, which pages each runs on, what it collects and who receives it.
- If you use a tag manager, ask for a screenshot of every tag in the container and what triggers it.
- Ask your booking, chat and form vendors whether their tools load any third party tracking, and whether they will sign a business associate agreement.
- Have someone open your booking page in a desktop browser with the developer tools open on the Network tab, complete a test booking, and look for requests to advertising and analytics domains.
Write down what you find. That inventory is the starting point for every decision that follows, and HHS's bulletin expects regulated entities to address tracking technologies in their risk analysis.
Your options
Once you know what is there, you have several choices, often in combination.
- Remove advertising pixels from booking, form, portal and other pages where patients enter health information
- Use analytics tools whose vendors will sign a business associate agreement, configured so they only collect what you need
- Stop tags from capturing form field values and page addresses that reveal a visit reason
- Host booking and portal pages where no marketing tags load at all
- Route data through a vendor that signs a business associate agreement and passes only de-identified information onward, an approach the HHS bulletin describes
HHS's bulletin also says some shortcuts do not work. Mentioning tracking in your privacy policy does not by itself permit a disclosure. A cookie consent banner is not a valid HIPAA authorization. And a vendor's promise to strip out protected health information after receiving it is not enough without a business associate agreement.
For measurement that stays on the right side of these lines, see HIPAA safe analytics and retargeting and HIPAA.
What is at stake
HHS notes that failing to comply with the HIPAA rules may result in civil money penalties, and that an impermissible disclosure of protected health information to a tracking vendor can require breach notification to affected individuals, to HHS and in some cases to the media. Beyond that is the cost no regulation measures: a patient who learns that their booking for a sensitive visit was shared with an ad platform may not come back.
The good news is that most practices can fix the highest risk pages quickly once they know what is on them. For the broader compliance picture, see tracking technology and patient privacy and HIPAA and AI chat widgets.
Checklist
- You have a written inventory of every tag and pixel, the pages it runs on and who receives its data
- No advertising pixel runs on booking, form, portal login or bill pay pages
- Every vendor that may receive protected health information has signed a business associate agreement, or receives nothing
- Tags do not capture form field values or visit reasons in page addresses
- Tracking technologies are addressed in your HIPAA risk analysis
- Your privacy counsel has reviewed the setup
Frequently asked
Did the 2024 court ruling make tracking pixels safe for medical websites?
No. The court vacated one part of HHS's guidance, about connecting an IP address with a visit to a public page about health conditions or providers. The vacated part was not about pages where patients book, enter symptoms or log in, and the HIPAA rules themselves still apply. This is general information, not legal advice.
Is Google Analytics allowed on a practice website?
The question is not the brand but what the tool receives and whether the vendor is a business associate. HHS guidance says any tracking vendor that receives protected health information needs a business associate agreement. Many practices keep standard analytics off sensitive pages or use a tool whose vendor will sign one. Ask your privacy counsel.
Does a cookie banner make tracking compliant?
Not for HIPAA purposes. HHS's bulletin states that website banners asking users to accept or reject cookies do not constitute a valid HIPAA authorization.
Our booking tool is from a third party. Is that our problem?
Yes, if it runs on your website and handles your patients' information. Ask the vendor what tracking their tool loads and whether they will sign a business associate agreement, and choose a different tool if the answers are unclear.
Sources
- Use of Online Tracking Technologies by HIPAA Covered Entities and Business Associates, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
- American Hospital Association v. Becerra, No. 4:23-cv-01110-P, Opinion and Order (N.D. Tex. June 20, 2024), U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas (copy posted by the American Hospital Association)
- Business Associates, U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.