Waitlists and same day openings: filling the slots you already have
Keep a structured waitlist of patients who want an earlier visit, with their visit type, provider preference and available times, and get their consent to be texted about openings. When a slot opens, offer it to the best matched patients at once and give it to the first to confirm. Separately, hold a few same day slots based on your own demand data and release them at a set time if they go unused.
An empty slot cannot be stored
A surgeon's open hour on Tuesday is gone on Wednesday. Unlike most businesses, a practice cannot put unsold time back on a shelf. Every cancellation that goes unfilled is lost capacity, and every patient who wanted to be seen sooner and was not is a patient who may book elsewhere.
Meanwhile, the same practice can have the opposite problem in the same week: new patients told the first opening is a month away. A waitlist connects the two. It turns your cancellations into visits for patients who are already waiting, and it shortens the wait that makes new patients look elsewhere.
Your scheduling system may already have a waitlist feature. The difference between practices that fill cancellations and those that do not is usually the routine around it, not the software.
Build a waitlist that is more than a sticky note
A waitlist only works if staff can match a slot to a patient in seconds. Capture these details when a patient joins:
- Name and preferred contact channel
- Visit type and length, such as new patient consult or 15 minute follow up
- Acceptable providers and locations
- Days and times they can come, and how much notice they need
- The latest date the visit is useful, after which they should be removed
- Date added, so older requests can get priority
- Consent to be texted about openings
Ask every patient who accepts a date more than a week or two out: "Would you like us to text you if something earlier opens up?" Record the answer where the scheduler will see it. Review the list weekly and remove patients whose dates have passed or who have already been seen.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Fill a cancellation in minutes
Speed matters, because the closer to the slot, the fewer patients can take it. Agree on a routine and write it down.
- When a cancellation comes in, check the waitlist for patients who match the visit type, length, provider and time.
- Text the top few matches at the same time, not one by one, with the exact slot: "An opening with Dr. Ruiz tomorrow at 10:40 am. Reply YES to take it."
- Give the slot to the first to confirm, and tell the others politely that it has been filled.
- Move the newly booked patient's old appointment back into the pool, and offer that slot in turn.
- If nobody responds within an hour or so, call one or two patients who said they can come on short notice.
After hours cancellations can be handled the same way by an automated system that matches and texts, or by a staff member first thing the next morning. Waitlist texts offer a new time rather than reminding a patient of an existing one, and the federal healthcare exemption for automated texts lists reminders and confirmations, not offers. Get the patient's agreement to these texts when they join the list. This is general information, not legal advice. See text to book for how two way texting can handle the replies.
Hold some same day slots on purpose
Waitlists fill cancellations. Same day slots meet demand that has not been booked yet: the patient with a sudden rash, a sprained ankle, an ear infection or a medication question who wants to be seen today.
Decide how many to hold from your own data, not a rule of thumb:
- For eight weeks, have the front desk log every request for a same day or next day visit, whether or not it was granted.
- Average the requests by day of the week. Mondays and Fridays may look quite different.
- Hold roughly that many slots per provider or per day, spread across morning and afternoon.
- Set a release time, such as late morning for afternoon slots, after which unused same day slots open to anyone, including the waitlist.
Review the log every quarter. If same day slots go unused, hold fewer. If patients are still turned away, hold more, or add a short visit type that fits between longer ones.
Tell patients when you can see them sooner
Open capacity only helps if patients know about it. A practice that can see new patients this week has a real advantage over one with a month long wait, but only if the patient can see that before they book elsewhere.
- Say it on your website, near the booking button: "Same week visits often available. Book online or call."
- Show real open times in your online booking, rather than a request form
- Mention same day or same week access in your Google Business Profile description and posts, if it is true
- Tell callers about the waitlist when the first available date is far out
Only promise what you can deliver. If availability changes, change the wording. The same clear statements help AI assistants describe your practice accurately, and connect to online scheduling that writes into your EHR, which is what lets a patient grab a freed up slot at 9 pm.
Measure the fill rate
Two numbers tell you whether the system works.
- Backfill rate: cancelled slots that were refilled, divided by all cancelled slots, for the month.
- Time to fill: how long, on average, between the cancellation and the new booking.
Add a third if you hold same day slots: the share of held slots that were used, by day of the week.
Track them monthly and look for patterns. If late cancellations rarely refill, the problem may be notice time, which a reminder a few days earlier can fix, as covered in no shows and reminders. If the waitlist is long but fills few slots, check whether staff are using it, and whether patients' availability details are complete. A waitlist that nobody checks is just a list.
Checklist
- Waitlist records visit type, provider, available times, latest useful date and texting consent
- Every patient offered a date more than a week or two out is asked to join the waitlist
- Written backfill routine: match, text several at once, first to confirm wins
- Same day requests logged for eight weeks to size the held slots
- A set release time for unused same day slots
- Website and Google profile mention same week access only when true
- Backfill rate and time to fill tracked monthly
Frequently asked
Is it fair to text several waitlist patients at once?
Yes, if you say so up front. Tell patients when they join that openings go to the first person who confirms, and always tell the others promptly when a slot is taken. It is faster than calling one at a time while the slot gets closer.
How many same day slots should we hold?
Base it on your own log of same day requests by weekday over several weeks. Hold roughly that many, set a release time, and adjust every quarter. Specialties with more urgent problems, such as primary care and pediatrics, tend to need more than surgical specialties.
Can our online booking show cancellations automatically?
If online booking reads directly from your live schedule, a cancelled slot can reappear for anyone to book. That helps fill it quickly, but it can bypass your waitlist. Decide which takes priority, and set a short delay before released slots appear online if needed.
What if a waitlist patient takes the slot and then does not show?
Treat it like any no show: reach out the same day and record the reason. If it happens often with short notice offers, confirm the slot with a second quick reply or a call, and ask patients to join the waitlist only for times they can truly make.
Sources
- 47 CFR 64.1200, Delivery restrictions, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.