What missed calls cost a practice, and how to work out your own number
Missed calls cost a practice the visits those callers would have booked, the long term value of the new patients among them, and the goodwill of existing patients who could not get through. You can estimate your own figure in under an hour from a week of phone logs, a small callback sample and what a new patient is worth to you.
Why the cost stays hidden
A missed call leaves almost no trace. Many callers hang up without leaving a message and dial the next practice on the list. The front desk remembers the morning the phones were slammed, not the forty rings nobody heard while they were checking in patients. The phone system counts every unanswered call, but few practices ever open that report.
So the cost never appears on a statement. It shows up indirectly, as a schedule with more open new patient slots than it should have, or ad spend that brings in calls and not visits. The way to see it is to count it.
Pull one week of call data
Ask whoever manages your phone system for one normal week of inbound call records. Most office phone systems and phone providers can export this. You want, for each call:
- Date and time
- The caller's number
- What happened: answered by a person, sent to voicemail, abandoned on hold or in the menu, or arrived after hours
Then clean it up:
- Remove duplicates. One person calling three times is one caller, though a frustrated one.
- Remove callers who got through later that week.
- Split known and unknown numbers. Numbers that match a chart in your EHR are existing patients. Unknown numbers are more likely new patients, referring offices or vendors.
- Sort by hour of day, which will matter when you fix it.
What is left is your count of people who tried to reach you and never did.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Work out your own number
Use your figures, not anyone else's. Five steps:
- Unreached callers. The cleaned count from your call data.
- How many were new patients. Call back a sample of the unknown numbers with a short, friendly script and ask what they needed, or use the share of unknown numbers as a rough stand in.
- How many would have booked. For one week, track the new patient calls your team does answer and how many end in a booking. Apply that rate.
- What a new patient is worth. A first visit undercounts it. Use a year of revenue per new patient, or your lifetime value estimate; see what a new patient is worth.
- Multiply. Weekly lost new patients, times value, times the weeks you are open.
A purely hypothetical example to show the math: say the week shows 60 unique callers who never reached anyone. The callback sample suggests about a third were new patients, so 20. Your team books about half of the new patient calls it answers, so roughly 10 lost new patients. If a new patient is worth $600 to your practice in the first year, that is $6,000 a week, or about $300,000 over a fifty week year. Your numbers will differ. The point is to calculate them.
The costs the formula leaves out
The math above counts new patients only. The rest of the damage is harder to price but just as real.
- Existing patients who could not reach you about a refill, a result or a follow up call again, clogging the lines further, or give up and go elsewhere
- Reviews that mention the phones, which future patients read before they ever call
- Referring offices whose staff cannot get through and start sending patients to a practice that answers
- Marketing spend that produces calls nobody picks up, which makes every channel look worse than it is
- Staff strain from a phone that never stops ringing while patients wait at the desk
If the new patient figure alone does not move you, list these next to it.
Find when the calls are missed
Your hour by hour sort usually shows a pattern. Common trouble spots are the first hour after opening, lunch, the last half hour of the day, Mondays and the day after a holiday. These are the moments when the same people answering phones are also checking patients in and out.
Check it yourself. Call your own main line at 8:05 am on a Monday and 12:15 pm on a Tuesday. Count the rings, time the menu, and note how long it takes to reach a person, if you do. Then call once after hours and listen to what a patient hears. Many patients will not leave a message at that point, for reasons covered in why patients do not leave voicemails.
Ways to recover missed calls
From cheapest to most involved:
- Staff to the peaks. Stagger lunches, and move phone duty away from the check in desk during the busiest hours.
- Return every missed call. Pull the missed call list every hour and call back within a set time. Unreturned missed calls are the most expensive kind.
- Offer a callback instead of hold. Many phone systems can let callers keep their place and get a call back.
- Overflow. Route unanswered calls to another location, a remote team member, an answering service or an AI receptionist, compared in AI receptionists versus answering services.
- Give callers another way in. Online booking and texting serve patients who would rather not call at all.
Some practices send an automatic text to every missed caller. That can work well, but it is an outbound text, and FCC rules require prior consent for autodialed texts to mobile phones. Check the setup with counsel and your texting vendor first; this is general information, not legal advice.
Once you have fixed the gaps, keep measuring. Call tracking shows which sources produce calls and how many are answered; see call tracking without losing your number.
Checklist
- You have pulled one normal week of inbound call records
- Duplicates and callers who got through later are removed
- You have estimated how many unreached callers were new patients
- Your own booking rate and new patient value are in the calculation
- You know which hours and days produce the most missed calls
- Every missed call is returned within a set time
- Overflow and after hours calls reach a person or a system that can help
Frequently asked
How many missed calls is normal for a practice?
There is no useful universal benchmark, and the right number is the one you can measure and improve. Pull a week of your own call data, count unique callers who never reached anyone, and track that figure monthly as you make changes.
Do callers who hang up without a voicemail really matter?
They are often the ones who matter most. A new patient with no relationship to your practice has little reason to wait for a callback, so they hang up and call the next office. Returning every missed call quickly recovers some of them.
Is call tracking needed to measure missed calls?
Not to start. Your phone system's own call records are usually enough for a one week study. Call tracking adds which marketing source produced each call, which helps when you want to know whether ads or listings are bringing in calls that go unanswered.
Sources
- Stop Unwanted Robocalls and Texts, Federal Communications Commission
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.