Cost per new patient versus cost per click
Cost per click is the price of a visit; cost per new patient is the price of a result. A campaign with expensive clicks can be the better buy if more of those clicks become kept appointments. Judge ads by cost per booked or kept new patient, and compare that with what a new patient is worth to your practice.
Cost per click is a price, not a result
Cost per click is the number most ad reports lead with, because the ad platform knows it exactly. It tells you what you paid for each visit to your site. It says nothing about whether the visit became a patient.
Focusing on it pushes campaigns in the wrong direction. The cheapest clicks are often the least useful: broad searches, informational queries, people far outside your area or people looking for a different service. An agency rewarded for a low cost per click can deliver exactly that.
Google's documentation does note that higher quality ads can often lead to lower costs per click, so a better ad and landing page can bring the price down over time. But price is still not the result. The result is a patient in a chair.
The chain from click to patient
Each step in the chain has its own cost, and each step tells you something different.
- Cost per click: spend divided by clicks
- Cost per lead: spend divided by calls, completed forms and booking starts
- Cost per booked new patient: spend divided by confirmed new patient appointments from the campaign
- Cost per kept new patient: spend divided by the new patients who actually came in
The further down the chain, the more useful the number and the harder it is to measure. Most practices can reach cost per booked new patient with basic conversion tracking and a monthly look at the schedule. Cost per kept patient also needs your no show data.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
An illustration with made up numbers
The numbers below are invented and rounded to keep the arithmetic easy. Replace them with your own.
Campaign A targets broad searches. It spends $1,500, gets 1,000 clicks at $1.50 each, and produces 10 booked new patients, of whom 8 keep the appointment. Cost per kept new patient: $187.50.
Campaign B targets specific searches for a service you are known for. It spends $1,500, gets 300 clicks at $5.00 each, and produces 20 booked new patients, of whom 18 keep the appointment. Cost per kept new patient: about $83.
Campaign B's clicks cost more than three times as much, yet each patient costs less than half as much. A report focused on cost per click would favor Campaign A. A report focused on patients would favor Campaign B, and so should you.
What a new patient is worth to you
A cost per patient only means something next to what that patient brings in, and that depends heavily on your specialty and payer mix.
- A primary care patient on a common insurance plan may generate modest revenue per visit but many visits over the years
- A patient for a cash pay cosmetic procedure may bring higher revenue from fewer visits
- A surgical patient may bring one large episode of care, with the margin depending on the payer
- A patient on a plan with low reimbursement may cost you money if your schedule is already full
Use your own numbers: average collections per visit for the service, the typical number of visits in the first year, and your margin after provider time and supplies. The method is in what a new patient is worth, and the payer question in the right patients, not more patients.
Find your break even
Your break even cost per new patient is the most you can pay to acquire one before that patient stops being profitable in the first year. A simple way to estimate it:
- Estimate first year collections for a typical new patient for the service you are advertising.
- Subtract the direct cost of delivering that care, such as provider time, staff and supplies.
- What remains is the most you could spend to acquire that patient and break even in year one.
Then decide how much of that you are willing to spend. It is prudent to set a target well below break even, to leave room for error and for profit. If a campaign's cost per kept new patient sits above your target for a couple of months, despite fixes to the page and the phone, it is a candidate to cut. See when to turn your ads off.
Where the numbers come from
You need three sources, brought together once a month.
- The ad platform: spend, clicks and tracked conversions per campaign
- Your schedule: new patient appointments booked and kept, by source where your intake records it
- Your billing data: average collections per new patient for the advertised service
Add agency fees and any landing page or tracking costs to the ad spend, because they are part of what each patient costs. None of this needs to be precise to be useful. A rough cost per booked new patient, calculated the same way every month, is far better than an exact cost per click that says nothing about patients.
Checklist
- You calculate cost per booked new patient for each campaign every month
- You know your no show rate, so you can estimate cost per kept patient
- You have estimated first year value for a new patient in each advertised service
- You have a written target cost per new patient, set below break even
- Agency fees are included when you calculate what a patient costs
- Your agency's reports include booked new patients, not only cost per click
Frequently asked
What is a good cost per new patient?
There is no universal figure. It depends on what a new patient is worth to your practice, which varies with specialty, payer mix and how many visits a patient typically has. A good cost per new patient is one comfortably below your own break even.
Why is our cost per click so high?
Click prices are set in an auction, so competition from other practices and health systems in your area drives them. Ad and landing page quality also affect what you pay. A high click price is acceptable if those clicks become patients at a cost you can afford.
How do we know which patients came from ads?
Combine conversion tracking in the ad account with a source field in your intake or scheduling records, and compare totals each month. Neither is perfect alone. Together they give a reasonable estimate.
Should we include the agency fee in cost per new patient?
Yes, for decisions about whether advertising pays. Add management fees and any landing page or tracking costs to ad spend when you calculate the true cost of a new patient from the channel.
Sources
- About Ad Rank, Google Ads Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.