"How did you hear about us?" and why it lies
Patients answer the question honestly but inaccurately: they remember the last step, compress a long search into one word like Google, and staff record whatever is quickest. Ask two short questions with a fixed list, record the answer in your practice management system, and read it alongside call tracking and booking data rather than on its own.
Why the answer is wrong so often
Picture a new patient with heel pain. A colleague mentioned a podiatrist months ago. Last week she searched for heel pain treatment, read an article on your site, forgot about it, saw your listing again on Google Maps two days later, checked your reviews, and called. When your front desk asks how she heard about you, she says Google.
She is not wrong. She is also not describing what happened. The question invites a single answer to a journey with several steps, and people tend to give the most recent or the most memorable one.
A few patterns repeat:
- Compression. Google can mean an ad, a map listing, an organic result or your own website. Patients rarely know the difference.
- The last step wins. The word of mouth recommendation that started the search gets lost.
- Courtesy. A patient referred by another physician may say a friend, or the reverse, depending on what feels right to say.
- Guessing. A patient who does not remember will pick something rather than say they do not know.
Where the question goes wrong at the front desk
Even a well designed question fails if it is asked badly. The common problems sit at the front desk, and they are not the staff's fault.
- Asked at the wrong moment. At the end of a long call, after insurance, date of birth and directions, the question gets rushed or skipped.
- A default answer. If the field defaults to internet or other, that is what gets recorded when the call is busy.
- Free text. Typed answers like goggle, web, internet search and online cannot be counted without cleanup.
- An old pick list. A list built years ago may include the Yellow Pages and lack your Business Profile, a marketplace you now use or a new referring group.
- Asked twice, answered differently. The phone scheduler and the online intake form ask separately and store the answers in different places.
The fix is to make the right answer the easy one, at a moment when the patient is not rushed.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
A better question, and a better list
Two short questions beat one long one.
- What made you choose us? A fixed list: referred by a doctor, recommended by a friend or family member, our reviews, our website, we accept your insurance, location, other.
- Where did you first find us? A fixed list: another doctor, a friend or family member, Google search, Google Maps, an insurance directory, a physician directory or booking site, social media, an ad, an event or mailer, not sure.
A few rules make the lists work:
- Always include not sure. A truthful not sure is more useful than a guess.
- When the answer is another doctor, capture which doctor. That turns a vague category into a referral relationship you can manage.
- Keep the list short enough to read aloud on the phone, ideally under ten options.
- Review the list once a year, and add any new channel you start paying for before the first dollar is spent.
If patients book online, ask the same questions with the same options in the booking or intake form, so the data from phone and web can be combined.
Record it where it can be counted
A referral source written on a sticky note or buried in a free text field is lost. Store it in your practice management system or EHR, in a structured field on the new patient record, so you can run a report of new patients by source for any month.
Many systems have a referral source field already. If yours does not, ask your vendor, or use a custom field with a fixed list. Make it required for new patients, with not sure as a valid answer, so it is never blank.
Then pull the report monthly, alongside your count of new patients booked. If you use the five numbers a practice owner should watch, this is where the fourth number comes from.
Check it against the data you already have
Self reported source is one witness. You have others, and the truth usually sits where they overlap.
- Call tracking shows which source made the phone ring, for the channels you track. See call tracking without losing your number.
- Your Business Profile's performance view shows calls, website clicks and direction requests from the profile.
- Your booking tool may record which page or link the booking came from.
- Search Console shows whether searches for your services, not just your name, are bringing visitors.
Look for agreement over several months rather than an exact match in any one. If patients increasingly say Google Maps and your profile's calls and direction requests rise in the same period, you can trust the trend. If patients say a radio campaign brought them but nothing else moved, be skeptical, and ask a few patients a follow up question.
What the question is still good for
For some sources, asking the patient is the only signal you have, and that is where the question earns its place.
- Referring physicians. No tool knows which physician's office sent the patient. Tracking referrals by doctor shows which relationships are growing and which are fading, which matters when a top referrer retires; see what happens when your top referring doctor retires.
- Word of mouth. Friends and family recommendations leave no digital trail.
- Offline marketing. Community events, health fairs, school partnerships and printed materials without a tracking number.
- Reputation. Our reviews as the reason for choosing you tells you what to protect.
Used this way, the question is not a scoreboard. It is a regular conversation with your patients about why they came, and that is worth having even when the answers are imperfect.
Checklist
- Two questions: what made you choose us, and where did you first find us
- Fixed pick lists of under ten options, each including not sure
- The referring doctor's name captured whenever the answer is another doctor
- Answers stored in a structured field in your practice management system
- The same questions and options on the phone and in online booking or intake
- A monthly report of new patients by source, read alongside call and profile data
- The list reviewed once a year and updated before any new paid channel starts
Frequently asked
Should we stop asking patients how they heard about us?
No. Ask it better. It is the only way to learn about referring physicians, word of mouth and offline marketing, and it gives you the patient's own reason for choosing you. Just do not treat the answers as precise attribution for digital channels.
Why do so many patients answer Google?
Because most journeys pass through Google at some point, and the word covers ads, the map listing, organic results and your website. Split Google into search and Maps in your list, and use your profile and Search Console data to understand the rest.
When is the best time to ask?
When the patient is not rushed. On the phone, ask while the scheduler is waiting for the booking to save, not at the end of the call. Online, put it in the booking or intake form. Avoid asking at check in, when patients are thinking about the visit.
Can we trust the answer for referrals from other doctors?
More than most, especially if you also receive the referral itself through fax, your EHR or a referral portal. Match the patient's answer against the referrals you received, and record the referring physician by name so you can track each relationship.
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.