Monthly website report: what to ask your agency for
Ask for one or two pages that lead with new patient inquiries and bookings by source, then show search visibility, then list the work done and what is planned next, with the same definitions every month and comparisons to last month and last year. Ask for direct access to the underlying accounts as well, so the report is a summary you can check, not the only view you have.
What a report is for
A monthly report has two jobs. It should tell you whether marketing produced new patients, and it should tell you what the people you pay did and what they will do next. Most reports do neither well. They show a lot of activity, in charts that change from month to month, and leave you to decide whether it was worth it.
The fix is not a longer report. It is a shorter one, with the outcome first and the same structure every month, so you can read it in five minutes and know whether to ask questions.
This applies to any vendor, including us, and to an in house marketing person. A good team welcomes clear expectations, because it makes their work visible.
The structure to ask for
Ask for these sections, in this order, every month.
- Outcomes. New patient inquiries by source: calls from new callers, online bookings, forms and chat. If the agency cannot see your schedule, ask them to include the new patient count your office provides, so the report puts inquiries next to bookings. Cost per new patient for each paid channel.
- Visibility. Clicks from Google Search, split between searches that include your practice name and searches that do not. Your Business Profile's calls, website clicks and direction requests, by location. Impressions in Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode from Search Console's generative AI report.
- Website health. Whether every booking button, phone link and form was tested and worked. Any important page that dropped out of Google's index. Any significant speed or error problem.
- Work done. What changed this month: pages published or updated, fixes made, campaigns adjusted. Link each item to the page or setting it changed.
- Next month. What they plan to do, and any decision they need from you.
That fits on two pages. Anything more can go in an appendix.
Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?
The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.
Definitions that stay the same
The fastest way to make a report meaningless is to change what the numbers mean. Agree on definitions once, in writing, and ask for them to be printed at the bottom of every report.
- New patient inquiry: which calls count (first time callers only, or all calls longer than a set time), which forms count, and whether online booking attempts that were not completed are included
- Source: how each inquiry is assigned to a channel, and which tool decides
- Business Profile calls: Google counts taps on the call button, not completed calls, so label the number accordingly
- Comparison periods: this month versus last month and versus the same month last year; Search Console keeps sixteen months, enough for that comparison
When the vendor changes a tool or a tracking method, the report should say so in the first line, with the month the change happened, so a jump or drop is not mistaken for performance.
Ask for access, not just reports
A report is a summary someone else prepared. You should also be able to look yourself, or have someone you trust look, without asking permission.
Ask for practice controlled ownership or administrator access to:
- Your Google Business Profiles
- Google Analytics
- Search Console
- Your ad accounts
- Your call tracking account, if you use one
- Your website's content management system and hosting
A vendor who resists giving you access to your own accounts is a vendor to question. See who owns your domain, hosting and content and agency red flags.
You do not have to log in every month. The point is that you can, and that the numbers in the report can be checked against the source.
Warning signs in a report
Some reports are built to impress rather than inform. Watch for these:
- No outcomes. Impressions, sessions and rankings, but no inquiries or new patients.
- A keyword ranking table chosen by the vendor. Positions for a hand picked list can rise while new patients fall, and they vary by location anyway.
- Changing charts. A different set of metrics each month makes trends impossible to see.
- Only good news. Every month has something that went down. A report that never says so is not complete.
- Totals without context. Website visits up, with no split between new patients, existing patients, staff and job seekers.
- AI visibility claims without a method. If a vendor reports how often AI assistants mention you, ask exactly which questions were asked, how often, and from where. See how to check what AI says about your practice today.
None of these proves bad work. Each one is a reason to ask a question.
Use the report in a monthly conversation
The report is most valuable as the agenda for a short monthly call.
Keep the call to thirty minutes and use the same order as the report: outcomes, visibility, health, work done, next month. Ask why, not just what. If inquiries rose, which pages or campaigns drove it? If bookings did not follow, is the problem on the phones, in the schedule, or with insurance? If a page lost traffic, what changed?
Bring someone from the front desk occasionally. They know which patients called confused about a service, which locations are full, and which visit types are hard to book, and that context makes the next month's plan better.
At the end of each call, agree the one or two things that matter most next month and write them down. Next month's report should start by saying whether they happened.
Checklist
- Outcomes first: new patient inquiries and bookings by source
- Searches with and without your practice name shown separately
- Business Profile calls, clicks and directions reported by location
- Booking buttons, phone links and forms tested every month
- Work done and next month's plan listed in plain language
- Written definitions printed at the bottom of every report
- Practice controlled access to every account the report draws on
Frequently asked
How long should a monthly marketing report be?
One or two pages for the main report, with any detail in an appendix. If you cannot see within five minutes whether new patient inquiries went up or down and why, the report is too long or in the wrong order.
Should rankings be in the report?
Only as supporting detail. Rankings vary by location and person, and a list of positions for chosen keywords can look good while new patients fall. Search Console clicks for searches that do not include your name are a more honest measure of search visibility.
Our agency says they cannot see new patient numbers. Is that normal?
Often, yes, because they do not have access to your schedule, and they should not have patient level data. The fix is simple: your office sends a monthly count of new patients, by location and source if possible, and the agency puts it in the report beside the inquiries they measured.
What should we do if the report always looks good but the schedule does not?
Ask for the outcomes section described here, with written definitions. Then compare inquiries with bookings for a few months. If inquiries are real and bookings are not following, look at phones and availability. If inquiries are not real, the report was measuring the wrong things.
Sources
- Understand your Business Profile performance & insights, Google Business Profile Help
- Generative AI performance report (Search), Search Console Help
- Connect Search Console to Google Analytics, Google Analytics Help
Book a strategy call with the team.
Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.