The five numbers a practice owner should watch

Updated November 14, 2026 · 5 min read
Short answer

Watch new patients booked, new patient inquiries, the share of inquiries that become appointments, where patients found you, and what each new patient costs by channel. Pull them monthly from your schedule, phones and a few free Google tools, and read them together, because the pattern tells you where the problem is.

Why five, and not fifty

A practice owner has time to look at a handful of numbers once a month and act on them. A marketing platform can produce hundreds. The problem with the hundreds is not that they are wrong; it is that they bury the few that drive decisions.

The five numbers below follow a patient from the moment they find you to the moment they are on your schedule, plus what it cost to get them there. Each one has a clear source, most of which you already have. Together they tell you whether marketing is working and, when it is not, which part of the chain broke.

Keep them on one page. If a number cannot be pulled the same way every month, fix the definition before you trust the trend.

The five numbers

  1. New patients booked. New patient appointments created this month, from your practice management system or EHR. Split by location and, if useful, by provider or visit type. This is the result; everything else explains it.
  2. New patient inquiries. Every first contact from a prospective patient: calls from new callers, online booking attempts, web forms and chat requests. Pull calls from your phone system or call tracking, and bookings and forms from the tools that receive them.
  3. Inquiry to appointment rate. New patients booked divided by new patient inquiries. This is your front door: phones answered, callbacks made, slots available, insurance handled.
  4. Where they found you. A simple split of new patients by source: Google search, your Google Business Profile, referrals from other physicians, word of mouth, ads, other. Combine what patients tell you with what your tools show.
  5. Cost per new patient, by paid channel. Spend on a channel divided by new patients from that channel. Ads, marketplaces, paid directories and agency fees all count.

If you track a sixth, make it no shows among new patients, because a booked visit that never happens is not a new patient.

See your Surge Score in about a minute

Does ChatGPT recommend your practice?

The Surge Score measures five things about your practice website: how often ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend you, your PageSpeed, your structured data, your indexing and your reviews, each with its evidence and date. Free.

Where each number comes from

Most of these come from systems you already pay for.

  • Schedule: your practice management system's report of new patient appointments, by created date rather than visit date, so the month you count is the month the patient chose you
  • Phones: your phone system's call log or a call tracking tool; count first time callers, not every call
  • Google Business Profile: the Performance view shows calls, website clicks, direction requests and, with a booking provider, bookings from your profile. Google counts a call as a tap on the call button, not a completed call, so treat it as a signal of interest
  • Search Console: clicks to your site from Google Search, which tells you whether search visibility is growing
  • Analytics: online booking starts and completions, and form submissions, set up as key events
  • Front desk: a referral source field on the new patient record; see "How did you hear about us?" and why it lies

If you link your Business Profile to Google Analytics, Google shows its metrics there for the last six months, summed across all linked profiles, which is handy for one practice and less so for a group that needs them by location.

Read them together: four common patterns

Each number alone is ambiguous. Together they point to a cause.

  • Visibility up, inquiries flat: more people find you but do not contact you. Look at the website and the profile: booking buttons, phone numbers, hours, reviews. See why ads fail on websites that do not convert.
  • Inquiries up, bookings flat: marketing is working and the front door is not. Look at answered calls, callback speed, appointment availability and insurance questions.
  • Bookings up, revenue flat: you are filling the schedule with the wrong visit types or payers. Split new patients by visit type and insurance.
  • Cost per new patient rising on one channel: competition, a weaker campaign or a tracking break. Check the tracking first, then the channel.

When everything drops at once, check for something outside marketing: a phone outage, a provider on leave, a website change, or a seasonal dip you also saw last year.

Set it up in one afternoon

You do not need software to start. A shared spreadsheet works.

  1. Make one row per month and one column per number, with a second tab for each location if you have several.
  2. Write the definition of each number at the top: what counts, from which system, by which date.
  3. Name the person who fills in each column. The office manager usually owns bookings and phones; your agency or marketing lead owns the Google numbers.
  4. Fill in the last twelve months if you can, so you have last year to compare against. Search Console keeps sixteen months of data, which covers it.
  5. Review it on the same day each month, with whoever can act on it.

Once the definitions are stable, ask your agency to report against them. See monthly website report: what to ask your agency for.

What to stop looking at

Some numbers feel important and rarely change a decision.

  • Impressions alone. Being seen is necessary, not sufficient. Look at impressions only next to clicks and inquiries.
  • Rankings for a list of keywords someone else chose. Positions vary by location and person, and a report of hand picked keywords can look good while new patients fall.
  • Bounce rate and time on page. A patient who finds your phone number in five seconds and calls has a short visit and a perfect outcome.
  • Social media followers. Useful for some practices, but not a measure of new patients.
  • Total website sessions. Staff, existing patients paying bills and job seekers all count. New patient actions matter more.

None of these is useless. They are diagnostic details, not the scoreboard.

Checklist

  • New patients booked pulled monthly from the schedule, by created date
  • New patient inquiries counted across calls, online booking, forms and chat
  • Inquiry to appointment rate calculated and reviewed with the front desk
  • New patients split by source using patient answers and tool data together
  • Cost per new patient calculated for every paid channel
  • Definitions written at the top of the sheet and kept the same month to month
  • Twelve months of history filled in so seasonality is visible

Frequently asked

Should we count calls or new patients?

Both, but they answer different questions. Calls and other inquiries measure whether marketing is generating interest. New patients booked measures the result. The ratio between them tells you how well your front desk and schedule convert that interest.

What is a good cost per new patient?

It depends on what a new patient is worth to your practice, which varies widely by specialty, payer mix and how long patients stay. Work out your own value per new patient first, then judge each channel against it rather than against someone else's average.

How often should we review these numbers?

Monthly is the right rhythm for most practices. Weekly figures swing too much to act on, and quarterly reviews let problems run for too long. Compare each month to the same month last year as well as to the month before.

Our Google Business Profile shows many calls but the front desk disagrees. Who is right?

Probably both. Google counts taps on the call button, not completed calls, so some taps never connect, and some calls reach a line that goes unanswered. Compare the profile's call count with your phone system's log to find out which.

Sources

  1. Understand your Business Profile performance & insights, Google Business Profile Help
  2. Connect Google Business Profile (GBP) to Google Analytics, Google Analytics Help
  3. Connect Search Console to Google Analytics, Google Analytics Help
  4. Performance report (Search results), Search Console Help
Prefer to talk it through?

Book a strategy call with the team.

Twenty minutes. We'll walk through the specific opportunities in your market and what a MedPracticeGrowth engagement would look like for your practice.

AI patient discovery audit

Is AI recommending you, or your competitor?

See who ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity recommend to patients in your area.

Free. Built by physicians.